| Category | Recipient |
| Worst Picture | An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn (Hollywood Pictures) |
| Armageddon (Touchstone) |
| The Avengers (Warner Bros.) |
| Godzilla (TriStar) |
| Spice World (Columbia) |
| Worst Actor | Bruce Willis in Armageddon, Mercury Rising, and The Siege as Harry Stamper, Art Jeffries and William Devereaux |
| Ralph Fiennes in The Avengers as John Steed |
| Ryan O'Neal in An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn as James Edmunds |
| Ryan Phillippe in 54 as Shane O'Shea |
| Adam Sandler in The Waterboy as Bobby Boucher |
| Worst Actress | The Spice Girls in Spice World as themselves |
| Yasmine Bleeth in BASEketball as Jenna Reed |
| Anne Heche in Psycho as Marion Crane |
| Jessica Lange in Hush as Martha Baring |
| Uma Thurman in The Avengers as Emma Peel |
| Worst Supporting Actor | Joe Eszterhas (as himself) in An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn |
| Sean Connery in The Avengers as Sir August de Wynter |
| Roger Moore in Spice World as The Chief |
| Joe Pesci in Lethal Weapon 4 as Leo Getz |
| Sylvester Stallone (as himself) in An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn |
| Worst Supporting Actress | Maria Pitillo in Godzilla as Audrey Timmonds |
| Ellen Albertini Dow in 54 as Disco Dottie |
| Jenny McCarthy in BASEketball as Yvette Denslow |
| Liv Tyler in Armageddon as Grace Stamper |
| Raquel Welch in Chairman of the Board as Grace Kosik |
| Worst Screen Couple | Leonardo DiCaprio and himself (as twins) in The Man in the Iron Mask |
| Ben Affleck and Liv Tyler in Armageddon |
| "Any combination of two characters, body parts or fashion accessories" in Spice World |
| "Any combination of two people playing themselves (or playing with themselves)" in An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn |
| Ralph Fiennes and Uma Thurman in The Avengers |
| Worst Remake or Sequel | The Avengers (Warner Bros.) (tie) |
| Godzilla (TriStar) (tie) |
| Psycho (Universal) (tie) (The only three-way tie in the awards' history.) |
| Lost in Space (New Line Cinema) |
| Meet Joe Black (Universal) (remake of Death Takes a Holiday) |
| Worst Director | Gus Van Sant for Psycho |
| Michael Bay for Armageddon |
| Jeremiah S. Chechik for The Avengers |
| Roland Emmerich for Godzilla |
| Alan Smithee (also known as Arthur Hiller) for An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn |
| Worst Screenplay | An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn, written by Joe Eszterhas |
| Armageddon, screenplay by Jonathan Hensleigh and J. J. Abrams, story by Robert Roy Pool and Jonathan Hensleigh, adaptation by Tony Gilroy and Shane Salerno |
| The Avengers, written by Don MacPherson, based on the television series created by Sydney Newman |
| Godzilla, screenplay by Dean Devlin and Roland Emmerich, story by Roland Emmerich, Dean Devlin, Ted Elliott & Terry Rossio |
| Spice World, written by Kim Fuller, idea by Fuller and the Spice Girls |
| Worst New Star | Joe Eszterhas (as himself) in An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn (tie) |
| Jerry Springer in Ringmaster as Jerry Farrelly (tie) |
| Barney in Barney's Great Adventure: The Movie as himself |
| Carrot Top in Chairman of the Board as Edison |
| The Spice Girls in Spice World as themselves |
| Worst Original Song | "I Wanna Be Mike Ovitz!" from An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn, written by Joe Eszterhas and Gary G-Wiz |
| "Barney, the Song" from Barney's Great Adventure: The Movie, written by Jerry Herman |
| "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" from Armageddon, written by Diane Warren (also Oscar-nominated) |
| "Storm" from The Avengers, written by Bruce Woolley, Chris Elliott, Marius deVries, Betsy Cook, and Andy Caine |
| "Too Much" from Spice World, written by the Spice Girls, Andy Watkins, and Paul Wilson |
| Worst Movie Trends of the Year | "Gidgets 'n' geezers (58-year-old leading men wooing 28-year-old leading ladies)" (referring to the likes of A Perfect Murder, Six Days, Seven Nights and Stepmom) |
| "If you've seen the trailer, why bother to see the movie?!? (previews that give away the film's entire plot)" |
| "30 minutes of story – conveyed in less than three hours! (l-o-n-g-e-r movies... shorter plots)" |
| "THX: The audio is deafening! (movie sound so loud it constitutes assault with a deafening weapon)" |
| "Yo quiero tacky tie-ins! (Mega-zillion-dollar cross-promotional overkill: Armageddon, Godzilla, etc.)" |
Gus Van Sant, Worst Director winner.
Bruce Willis, Worst Actor winner.
Spice Girls, Worst Actress winners.
Maria Pitillo, Worst Supporting Actress winner.
Leonardo DiCaprio, Worst Screen Couple winner.
Jerry Springer, Worst New Star co-winner.
