Donetsk People's Republic
 | This article needs to be updated. (October 2022) |
Donetsk People's Republic Донецкая Народная Республика | |
|---|---|
 Coat of arms | |
| Anthem: Государственный гимн Донецкой Народной Республики Gosudarstvennyy gimn Donetskoy Narodnoy Respubliki "State Anthem of the Donetsk People's Republic" | |
![Territory of Ukraine's Donetsk Oblast controlled by Russia as DPR shown in red and pink; territory claimed but not controlled shown in yellow and blue[2]](File:Russian_Occupation_of_Donetsk_Oblast.svg) Territory of Ukraine's Donetsk Oblast controlled by Russia as DPR shown in red and pink; territory claimed but not controlled shown in yellow and blue[2] | |
.svg) DPR in its borders claimed by Russia shown in red, along with other disputed territories hatched | |
| Coordinates: 48°08′N 37°44′E / 48.14°N 37.74°E | |
| Country | Russia (partly controlled; internationally recognized as part of Ukraine) |
| Federal district | Southern[1] |
| Established | 7 April 2014[3] (as a breakaway state) 30 September 2022 (as a republic of Russia) |
| Administrative centre | Donetsk |
| Government | |
| • Body | People's Council |
| • Head | Denis Pushilin |
| • Prime Minister | Yevgeny Solntsev |
| Population | |
| • Total | ? |
| Time zone | UTC+3 (MSK[4]) |
| License plates | 80, 180[5] |
| OKTMO ID | 21000000 |
| Official language | Russian[6] |
| Website | днронлайн |
The Donetsk People's Republic (DPR; Russian: Донецкая Народная Республика (ДНР), romanized: Donetskaya Narodnaya Respublika (DNR), IPA: [dɐˈnʲetskəjə nɐˈrodnəjə rʲɪˈspublʲɪkə]) is a republic of Russia, comprising the occupied parts of eastern Ukraine's Donetsk Oblast,[7][8] with its capital in Donetsk. The DPR was created by Russian-backed paramilitaries in 2014,[9][10] and it initially operated as a breakaway state until it was illegally annexed in 2022. The entire territory of DPR is viewed as sovereign territory of Ukraine by nearly all UN member states.
Following Ukraine's Revolution of Dignity in 2014, pro-Russian, counter-revolutionary unrest erupted in the eastern part of the country. Russia annexed Crimea from Ukraine, while armed separatists seized government buildings and proclaimed the Donetsk People's Republic (DPR) and Luhansk People's Republic (LPR) as independent states. This sparked the war in Donbas, part of the wider Russo-Ukrainian War. The DPR and LPR are often described as puppet states of Russia during this conflict.[11][12][13] They received no international recognition from any United Nations member state before 2022.
On 21 February 2022, Russia recognised the DPR and LPR as sovereign states. Three days later, it launched a full-scale invasion of Ukraine, partially under the pretext of protecting the republics. Russian forces captured more of Donetsk Oblast, which became part of the DPR. In September 2022, Russia proclaimed the annexation of the DPR and other occupied territories, following referendums widely described as fraudulent by commentators. The United Nations General Assembly passed a resolution calling on countries not to recognise what it called the "attempted illegal annexation" and demanded that Russia "immediately, completely and unconditionally withdraw".[14][15]
The Head of DPR is Denis Pushilin, and its parliament is the People's Council. The ideology of the DPR is shaped by right-wing Russian nationalism, Russian imperialism, and Orthodox fundamentalism.[16] Russian far-right groups played an important role among the separatists, especially at the beginning of the conflict.[17] Organizations such as the UN Human Rights Office and Human Rights Watch have reported human rights abuses in the DPR, including internment, torture, extrajudicial killings, and forced conscription,[18] as well as political and media repression. The DPR People's Militia has also been held responsible for war crimes, among them the shooting down of Malaysia Airlines Flight 17.[19] Ukraine views the DPR and LPR as terrorist organisations.[20]
History
The Luhansk and Donetsk Peoples Republics are located in the historical Donbas region of Eastern Ukraine. Since Ukraine's independence from the Soviet Union in 1991, Eastern and Western Ukraine typically have voted for different candidates in presidential elections. Viktor Yanukovych, a Donetsk native, was elected as President of Ukraine in 2010. Eastern Ukrainian dissatisfaction with the government can also be attributed to the Euromaidan Protests which began in November 2013,[21] as well as Russian support[22] due to tension in Russia–Ukraine relations over Ukraine's geopolitical orientation.[23] President Yanukovych's overthrow in the 2014 Ukrainian revolution led to protests in Eastern Ukraine, which gradually escalated into an armed conflict between the newly formed Ukrainian government and the local armed militias.[24] The pro-Russian unrest in Ukraine was originally characterised by riots and protests which had eventually escalated into the storming of government offices.[25]
In 2011, Ukrainian Luhansk and Donetsk oblasts had a combined population of 6,1mln. As a result of Russian military aggression in 2014, 2 million had to leave the region as refugees. After full-scale Russian invasion in 2022, under the false pretext of "genocide of Russian speakers", another approx. 3 mln. either fled or were killed, resulting in total in 80% decrease of Donbas population. According to political scientist Taras Kuzio, this amounts to "destruction, depopulation, and genocide".[26]
Formation (2014–2015)
Foundations
On 6 April, 2014, pro-Russian rebel leaders announced that a referendum on whether Donetsk Oblast should "join the Russian Federation", would take place "no later than May 11th, 2014."[27] Additionally, the group's leaders appealed to Russian President Vladimir Putin to send Russian peacekeeping forces to the region.[27][28]
On 7 April, between 1,000 and 2,000[29] people attended a rally in Donetsk pushing for a Crimea-style referendum on independence from Ukraine. Ukrainian media claimed that the proposed referendum had no status quo option.[30] Afterwards, 200–1,000 separatists[31][29] stormed and took control of the first two floors of the government headquarters of the Regional State Administration (RSA), breaking down doors and smashing windows. The separatists demanded a referendum to join Russia, and said they would otherwise take unilateral control and dismiss the elected government.[32][33][34] When the session was not held, the unelected separatists held a vote within the RSA building and overwhelmingly backed the declaration of a Donetsk People's Republic.[35] According to the Russian ITAR-TASS, the declaration was voted by some regional legislators, while Ukrainian media claimed that neither the Donetsk city council nor district councils of the city delegated any representatives to the session.[36][37]
The political leadership initially consisted of Denis Pushilin, self-appointed as chairman of the government,[38][39] while Igor Kakidzyanov was named as the commander of the People's Army.[40] Vyacheslav Ponomarev became the self-proclaimed mayor of the city of Sloviansk.[41] Ukrainian-born pro-Russian activist Pavel Gubarev,[42][43] an Anti-Maidan activist, a former member of the neo-Nazi Russian National Unity paramilitary group in 1999–2001 and former member of the nazbol Progressive Socialist Party of Ukraine, proclaimed himself the People's Governor of the Donetsk Region.[44][45][46][47] He was arrested on charges of separatism and illegal seizure of power but released in a hostage swap.[48][42] Alexander Borodai, a Russian citizen claiming to be involved in the Russian annexation of Crimea, was appointed as prime minister, while Igor Girkin was made Defence Minister. Borodai had a past working for an openly anti-semitic and fascist Russian newspaper Zavtra which had called for pogroms against Jews.[49][50]
On the morning of 8 April, the 'Patriotic Forces of Donbas', a pro-Kyiv group that was formed on 15 March earlier that year by 13 pro-Kyiv NGOs, political parties and individuals,[51][52] issued a statement "cancelling" the other group's declaration of independence, citing complaints from locals.[53][54][55]
The Donetsk Republic organisation continued to occupy the RSA and upheld all previous calls for a referendum and the release of their leader Pavel Gubarev.[56][a] On 8 April, about a thousand people rallied in front of the RSA listening to speeches about the Donetsk People's Republic and to Soviet and Russian music.[57] Ukrainian media stated that a number of Russian citizens, including one leader of a far-right militant group, had also taken part in the events.[58]
12 April saw the start of a military conflict. Russian nationalist and former intelligence officer Igor "Strelkov" Girkin led an armed team of 52 volunteers and mercenaries from Crimea, where he had participated in the Russian occupation of the peninsula, to seize police and government buildings in Sloviansk, Donetsk Oblast.[59]: 14–17 Girkin's unit drove off an initial response by the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) and successive assaults by government, in what was to become an eighty-four day siege.[59]: 14–17 Girkin later said that he had been "the one who pulled the trigger of war".[60]
On 15 April 2014, acting Ukrainian President Olexander Turchynov announced the start of a military counteroffensive to confront the pro-Russian militants, and on 17 April, tensions de-escalated as Russia, the US, and the EU agreed on a roadmap to eventually end the crisis.[61][62] However, officials of the People's Republic ignored the agreement and vowed to continue their occupations until a referendum was accepted or the government in Kyiv resigned.[63]
The OSCE reported that all the main institutions of the city observed by the Monitoring Mission seemed to be working normally as of 16 April.[64] On 22 April, separatists agreed to release the session hall of the building along with two floors to state officials.[65] The ninth and tenth floors were later released on 24 April.[66] On the second day of the Republic, organisers decided to pour all of their alcohol out and announce a prohibition law after issues arose due to excessive drinking in the building.[67]
On 7 May, Russian president Vladimir Putin asked the separatists to postpone the proposed referendum to create the necessary conditions for dialogue. Despite Putin's comments, the Donetsk Republic group said they would still carry out the referendum.[68] The same day, Ukraine's security service (SBU) released an alleged audio recording of a phone call between a Donetsk separatist leader and leader of one of the splinter groups of former Russian National Unity Alexander Barkashov.[69] In the call, the voice said to be Barkashov insisted on falsifying the results of the referendum.[70] SBU stated that this tape is a definitive proof of the direct involvement of Russian government with preparations for the referendum.[69]
Ukrainian authorities released separatist leader Pavel Gubarev and two others in exchange for three people detained by the Donetsk Republic.[71]
Polling during this period indicated that around 18 per cent of Donetsk Oblast residents supported the seizures of administrative buildings while 72 per cent disapproved. Twelve per cent were in favour of Ukraine and Russia uniting into a single state, a quarter were in favour of regional secession to join Russia, 38.4 per cent supported federalisation, 41.1 per cent supported a unitary Ukraine with decentralised power, and 10.6 per cent supported the status quo.[72][73] In an August 2015 poll, with 6500 respondents from 19 cities of Donetsk Oblast, 29 per cent supported the DPR and 10 per cent considered themselves to be Russian patriots.[74]
11 May independence referendum
The planned referendum was held on 11 May, disregarding Vladimir Putin's appeal to delay it.[75] The organisers claimed that 89% voted in favour of self-rule, with 10% against, on a turnout of nearly 75%. The results of the referendums were not officially recognised by any government;[76] Germany and the United States also stated that the referendums had "no democratic legitimacy",[77] while the Russian government expressed respect for the results and urged a civilised implementation.[78]
On the day after the referendum, the People's Soviet of the DPR proclaimed Donetsk to be a sovereign state with an indefinite border and asked Russia "to consider the issue of our republic's accession into the Russian Federation".[citation needed] It also announced that it would not participate in the Ukrainian presidential election which took place on 25 May.[79]
The first full Government of the DPR was appointed on 16 May 2014.[80] It consisted of several ministers who were previously Donetsk functionaries, a member of the Makiivka City Council, a former Donetsk prosecutor, a former member of the special police Alpha Group, a member of the Party of Regions (who allegedly coordinated "Titushky" (Viktor Yanukovych supporters) during Euromaidan) and Russian citizens.[80] This government imposed martial law on 16 July.[81]
Elections in the DPR and LPR were held on 2 November 2014, after the territories had boycotted the 2014 Ukrainian parliamentary election on 26 October.[82] The results were not recognised by any country.[83][84]
The DPR adopted a memorandum on 5 February 2015, declaring itself the successor to the Donetsk–Krivoy Rog Soviet Republic and Bolshevik revolutionary Fyodor Sergeyev—better known by his alias "Artyom"—as the country's founding father.[85]
Stalemate (2015–2022)
On 1 January 2015, the Russian ruble went into official circulation with parallel circulation of the Ukrainian hryvnia permitted until 1 September 2015, however, taxes and fees were to be paid in rubles only, and the wages of employees at budget-receiving organisations were to be paid out in rubles as well.[86]
On 12 February 2015, the DPR and LPR leaders, Alexander Zakharchenko and Igor Plotnitsky, signed the Minsk II agreement.[87] According to the agreement, amendments to the Ukrainian constitution should be introduced, including "the key element of which is decentralisation" and the holding of elections in the LPR and DPR within the lines of the Minsk Memorandum. In return, the rebel-held territory would be reintegrated into Ukraine.[87][88] In an effort to stabilise the ceasefire in the region, particularly the disputed and strategically important town of Debaltseve, Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko called for a UN-led peacekeeping operation in February 2015 to monitor compliance with the Minsk agreement.[89] The Verkhovna Rada did not ratify the changes in the constitution needed for the Minsk agreement.[90][91][92]
On 20 May 2015, the leadership of the Federal State of Novorossiya, a proposed confederation of the DPR and LPR, announced the termination of the confederation project.[93][94]
On 15 June 2015, several hundred people protested in the centre of Donetsk against the presence of BM-21 "Grad" launchers in a residential area. The launchers had been used to fire at Ukrainian positions, provoking return fire and causing civilian casualties.[95] A DPR leader said that its forces were indeed shelling from residential areas (mentioning school 41 specifically), but that "the punishment of the enemy is everyone's shared responsibility".[96]
On 2 July 2015, DPR leader Aleksandr Zakharchenko ordered local elections to be held on 18 October 2015 "in accordance with the Minsk II agreements".[98] The 2015 Ukrainian local elections were set for 25 October 2015.[99] This was condemned by Ukraine.[98]
On 4 September 2015, there was a sudden change in the DPR government, where Denis Pushilin replaced Andrey Purgin in the role of speaker of the People's Council and, in his first decision, fired Aleksey Aleksandrov, the council's chief of staff, Purgin's close ally. This happened in absence of Purgin and Aleksandrov who were held at the border between Russia and DPR, preventing their return to the republic. Aleksandrov was accused of "destructive activities" and an "attempt to illegally cross the border" by the republic's Ministry of Public Security. Russian and Ukrainian media commented on these events as yet another coup in the republic's authorities.[100][101]
After a Normandy four meeting in which the participants agreed that elections in territories controlled by DPR and LPR should be held according to Minsk II rules, both postponed their planned elections to 21 February 2016.[102] Vladimir Putin used his influence to reach this delay.[103] The elections were then postponed to 20 April 2016 and again to 24 July 2016.[104] On 22 July the elections were again postponed to 6 November.[105]
In July 2016, over a thousand people, mainly small business owners, protested in Horlivka against corruption and taxes, which included charging customs fees on imported goods.[106]
On 2 October 2016, the DPR and LPR held primaries in were voters voted to nominate candidates for participation in the 6 November 2016 elections.[107] Ukraine denounced these primaries as illegal.[107] The DPR finally held elections on 11 November 2018. These were described as "predetermined and without alternative candidates"[108] and not recognised externally.[109]
On 16 October 2016, a prominent Russian citizen and DPR military leader Arsen Pavlov was killed by an improvised explosive device in his Donetsk apartment's elevator.[110] Another DPR military commander, Mikhail Tolstykh, was killed by an explosion while working in his Donetsk office on 8 February 2017.[111] On 31 August 2018, Head and Prime Minister Alexander Zakharchenko was killed in an explosion in a cafe in Donetsk.[112] After his death Dmitry Trapeznikov was appointed as head of the government until September 2019 when he was nominated mayor of Elista, capital of Kalmyk Republic in Russia.[113] According to Ukrainian authorities, 50 Ukrainian soldiers were killed in clashes with Donbas separatists in 2020.[114]
In January 2021, the DPR and LPR stated in a "doctrine Russian Donbas" that they aimed to seize all of the territories of Donetsk and Luhansk Oblast under control by the Ukrainian government "in the near future".[115] The document did not specifically state the intention of DPR and LPR to be annexed by Russia.[115]
Russian invasion of Ukraine (since 2022)
The general mobilization in the Donetsk People's Republic began on 19 February 2022; five days before the start of Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine. Tens of thousands of local residents were forcibly mobilized for the war. According to the Eastern Human Rights Group, as of mid-June, about 140,000 people were forcibly mobilized in the DPR and LPR, of which from 48,000 to 96,000 were sent to the front and the rest to logistics support.[116][117]
On 21 February 2022, Russia recognised the independence of the DPR and LPR.[118] The next day, the Federation Council of Russia authorised the use of military force, and Russian forces openly advanced into the separatist territories.[119] Russian president Vladimir Putin declared that the Minsk agreements "no longer existed", and that Ukraine, not Russia, was to blame for their collapse.[120] A Russian military attack into Ukrainian government-controlled territory began on the morning of 24 February,[121] when Putin announced a "special military operation" to "demilitarise and denazify" Ukraine.[122][123]
In the course of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, around 55% of Donetsk Oblast came under the control of Russia and the DPR by June 2022.[124] In the south of Donetsk Oblast, the Russian Armed Forces laid siege to Mariupol for almost three months.[125] According to Ukrainian sources, an estimated 22,000 civilians were killed[126] and 20,000 to 50,000 were illegally deported to Russia by June 2022.[127][128][129] A vehicle convoy of 82 ethnic Greeks was able to leave the city via a humanitarian corridor.[130][131]
.jpg)
On 19 April 2022, a town hall assembly was reportedly organized in Russian-occupied Rozivka, where a majority of attendees (mainly seniors) voted by hand to join the Donetsk People's Republic. This came despite two hurdles: the raion was outside the borders claimed by the DPR, and the raion had not existed since 18 July 2020. The vote was claimed to be rigged, and organizers threatened anyone voting against it with arrest.[132][133]
On 21 May 2022, the town of Oskil in the Kharkiv Oblast was declared part of the DPR.[134] The town was later recaptured by Ukrainian forces during the Kharkiv Counteroffensive.
Dmitry Medvedev, the former Russian president and as of July 2022 vice chairman of the Russian Security Council, in July 2022 shared a map of Ukraine where most of Ukraine, including DPR, had been absorbed by Russia.[135]
Der Spiegel reported that forcibly recruited men from Donbas were used as cannon fodder. According to DPR officials, more than 3,000 were killed and over 13,000 wounded, "a casualty rate of 80 percent of the initial fighting force."[136] Human rights activists reported a huge – up to 30,000 people as of August 2022 – death toll among mobilized recruits in clashes with the well-trained Armed Forces of Ukraine.[116][117] On 16 August 2022, Vladimir Putin stated that "the objectives of this operation are clearly defined – ensuring the security of Russia and our citizens, protecting the residents of Donbass from genocide."[137]
Annexation by Russia
On 20 September 2022, the People's Council of the Donetsk People's Republic scheduled a referendum on the republic's entry into Russia as a federal subject for 23–27 September.[138] It was widely described as a sham referendum by commentators and denounced by various countries. On 21 September, Russian President Putin announced a partial mobilization in Russia. He said that "in order to protect our motherland, its sovereignty and territorial integrity, and to ensure the safety of our people and people in the liberated territories", he decided to declare a partial mobilization.[139] On 30 September 2022, Russia's president Vladimir Putin announced the annexation of the DPR along with the Luhansk People's Republic and two other oblasts of Ukraine in an address to both houses of the Russian parliament. On 12 October 2022, the United Nations General Assembly voted in Resolution ES-11/4 to condemn the annexation. The resolution received a vast majority of 143 countries in support of condemning Russia's annexation, 35 abstaining, and only 5 against condemning Russia's annexation.[15]
Government and politics
In early April 2014, a Donetsk People's Council was formed out of protesters who occupied the building of the Donetsk Regional Council on 6 April 2014.[32][33][140] The New York Times described the self-proclaimed state as neo-Soviet,[141] while Al Jazeera described it as neo-Stalinist and a "totalitarian, North Korea-like statelet".[142] Administration proper in DPR territories was performed by those authorities which performed these functions prior to the war in Donbas.[143] The DPR leadership has also appointed mayors.[144][145] Some sources described the "Donetsk People's Republic" during this period as a Russian puppet government.[146][147][148]
On 5 February 2020, Denis Pushilin unexpectedly appointed Vladimir Pashkov, a Russian citizen and former deputy governor of Russia's Irkutsk Oblast, as the chairman of the government.[149] This appointment was received in Ukraine as a demonstration of direct control over DPR by Russia.[150]
Several Russian officials were appointed to cabinet posts and prime ministership of the DPR in June and July 2022.[151]
Head
The Head of the Donetsk People's Republic (Russian: Глава Донецкой Народной Республики, romanized: Glava Donetskoy Narodnoy Respubliki) is the highest office of the Donetsk People's Republic. The following persons have occupied the post:
- Alexander Zakharchenko (1976–2018) 4 November 2014 – 31 August 2018 †. Political party: Donetsk Republic[152][153]
- Dmitry Trapeznikov (born 1981) Acting 31 August 2018 – 7 September 2018. Independent[154]
- Denis Pushilin (born 1981) 7 September 2018 – Incumbent (Acting: 7 September 2018 – 20 November 2018). Political party: Donetsk Republic, later United Russia[155]
Legislature
The parliament of the Donetsk People's Republic is the People's Council[156] and has 100 deputies.[82]
Passports and citizenship
In March 2016, the DPR began to issue passports[157] despite a 2015 statement by Zakharchenko that, without at least partial recognition of DPR, local passports would be a "waste of resources".[157] In November 2016 the DPR announced that all of its citizens had dual Ukrainian/Donetsk People's Republic citizenship.[158]
In June 2019, Russia started giving Russian passports to the inhabitants of the DPR and Luhansk People's Republic under a simplified procedure allegedly on "humanitarian grounds" (such as enabling international travel for eastern Ukrainian residents whose passports have expired).[159] Since December 2019 Ukrainian passports are no longer considered a valid identifying document in the DPR, and Ukrainian licence plates have been declared illegal.[160] Meanwhile, the previous favourable view of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in the DPR press was replaced with personal accusations of genocide and "crimes against Donbas", and proposals of organising a tribunal against him in absentia.[160] In March 2020 Russian was declared to be the only state language of the DPR;[161][unreliable source?] previously in its May 2014 constitution, the DPR had declared both Russian and Ukrainian its official languages.[80]
According to the Ukrainian press, by mid-2021, local residents received half a million Russian passports.[162] Deputy Kremlin Chief of Staff Dmitry Kozak stated in a July 2021 interview with Politique internationale that 470,000 local residents had received Russian passports; he added that "as soon as the situation in Donbass is resolved ....The general procedure for granting citizenship will be restored."[163]
Military
The Donbas People's Militia was formed by Pavel Gubarev, who was elected People's Governor of Donetsk Oblast and Igor Girkin, appointed the Minister of Defence of the Donetsk People's Republic.[164] The People's Militia of the DPR (Russian: Вооружённые силы ДНР) comprise the Russian separatist forces in the DPR. On 10 January 2020 president of the non-recognised pro-Russian Abkhazia accused DPR of staging a coup in his country. DPR commander Akhra Avidzba was commanding on the spot.[165] Unlike South Ossetia, Abkhazia had not then recognised DPR.[166]
The award Hero of the Donetsk People's Republic (Russian: Герой Донецкой Народной Республики) was bestowed on
- Joseph Kobzon – Russian actor[167]
- Ramzan Kadyrov — Head of Chechen Republic[168]
Problems of governance
OSCE monitors met with the self-proclaimed mayor of Sloviansk, Volodymyr Pavlenko, on 20 June 2014.[169] According to him, sewage systems in Sloviansk had collapsed, resulting in the release of least 10,000 litres of untreated sewage into the river Sukhyi Torets, a tributary of the Seversky Donets. He called this an "environmental catastrophe", and said that it had the potential to affect both Russia and Ukraine.[169]
As of May 2014, the Ukrainian Government was paying wages and pensions for the inhabitants of the DPR.[170][171][172] The closing of bank branches led to problems in receiving these,[173][174][175] especially since the National Bank of Ukraine ordered banks to suspend financial transactions in places which are not controlled by the Ukrainian authorities on 7 August 2014.[176] Only the Oschadbank (State Savings Bank of Ukraine) continued to function in territories controlled by the DPR, but it also closed its branches there on 1 December 2014.[176][177] In response, tens of thousands of pensioners have registered their address as being in Ukrainian-controlled areas while still living in separatist-controlled areas, and must travel outside of separatist areas to collect their pensions on a monthly basis.[178]
In October 2014, the DPR announced the creation of its own central bank and tax office, obliging residents to register to the DPR and pay taxes to it.[179] Some local entrepreneurs refused to register.[179]
According to the National Security and Defense Council of Ukraine a number of local mutinies have taken place due to unpaid wages and pensions, the council claims that on 24 November 2014, the local "Women Resistance Battalion" presented to Zakharchenko an ultimatum to get out of Donetsk in two months.[180]
Since April 2015, the DPR has been issuing its own vehicle number plates.[181]
The OSCE Special Monitoring Mission to Ukraine reported that in the DPR, "parallel 'justice systems' have begun operating".[182] They found this new judiciary to be "non-transparent, subject to constant change, seriously under-resourced and, in many instances, completely non-functional".[182]
Law and order
The Ministry of Internal Affairs is the DPR's agency responsible for implementing law and order.[183]
In 2014, the DPR introduced the death penalty for cases of treason, espionage, and assassination of political leaders. There had already been accusations of extrajudicial execution.[184] After 2015 a number of DPR and LPR field commanders and other significant figures were killed or otherwise removed from power.[185][186] This included Cossack commander Pavel Dryomov, commander of Private Military Company (ЧВК) Dmitry Utkin ("Wagner"), Alexander Bednov ("Batman"), Aleksey Mozgovoy, Yevgeny Ishchenko, Andrei Purgin and Dmitry Lyamin (the last two arrested).[187][188] In August 2016 Igor Plotnitsky, head of LPR, was seriously injured in a car bombing attack in Luhansk.[189] In September 2016 Evgeny Zhilin (Yevhen Zhylin), leader of the separatist "Oplot" unit, was killed in a restaurant near Moscow.[190][191] In October 2016 military commander Arseniy Pavlov ("Motorola") was killed by an IED planted at his house.[192] In February 2017 a bomb planted in an office killed Mikhail Tolstykh ("Givi").[193] On 31 August 2018 DPR leader Alexander Zakharchenko was killed by a bomb in a restaurant in Donetsk.[153] The DPR and Russia blamed the Security Service of Ukraine; Ukraine rejected these accusations, stating that Zakharchenko's death was the result of civil strife in the DPR.[186]
In May 2015, Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko signed four laws concerning decommunisation in Ukraine. Various cities and many villages in Donbas were renamed. The Ukrainian decommunisation laws were condemned by the DPR.[194]
In addition to Ukrainian prisoners of war there are reports of "thousands" of prisoners who were arrested as part of internal fighting between various militant groups inside DPR.[195]
Political scientist Stephen Shenfield summarizes the witness account of life in DPR as
- Political repressions on a level of Stalin's terror
- Power and wealth concentrated in hands of an elite
- Industrial base destroyed by fighting, stolen, or moved to Russia
- Large unemployment rate due to the destruction of the industry, and former workers joining armed formations to get paid.[196]
In 2022, during the Russian invasion of Ukraine, three soldiers of the Armed Forces of Ukraine, Aiden Aslin, Shaun Pinner, and Brahim Saadoune, were sentenced to death. The DPR lifted the death penalty moratorium.[197]
Ideology
According to a 2016 report by the French Institute of International Relations (IFRI), Russian ethnic and imperialist nationalism has shaped the official ideology of the Donetsk and Luhansk People's Republics.[198] During the war in Donbas, especially at the beginning, far-right groups played an important role on the pro-Russian side, arguably more so than on the Ukrainian side.[198][199]
According to Marlène Laruelle, separatist ideologues in Donbas produced an ideology composed of three strands of Russian nationalism: neo-fascist, Orthodox, and neo-Soviet.[199] Journalist Andrew Kramer observed that the DPR had effectively institutionalized nostalgia for the Soviet Union in the territories under its control, and reintroduced some socialist state policies, including the nationalization of the mining industry and commercial agriculture.[141]
Members and former members of neo-Nazi group Russian National Unity (RNU), as well as the National Bolshevik Party, Eurasian Youth Union, and Cossack groups, formed branches to recruit volunteers for the separatists.[198][200][201][202] A former RNU member, Pavel Gubarev, was founder of the Donbas People's Militia and first "governor" of the Donetsk People's Republic.[198][203] RNU is particularly linked to the Russian Orthodox Army,[198] one of a number of separatist units described as "pro-Tsarist" and "extremist Orthodox" nationalists.[204][198] Neo-Nazi unit 'Rusich'[198] is part of the Wagner Group, a Russian mercenary group in Ukraine which has been linked to far-right extremism.[205][206]
Some of the most influential far-right nationalists among the Russian separatists are neo-imperialists, who seek to revive the Russian Empire.[198] These included Igor 'Strelkov' Girkin, the minister of defence of the Donetsk People's Republic, who espouses Russian neo-imperialism and ethno-nationalism.[198] The Russian Imperial Movement, a white supremacist militant group,[205] has recruited thousands of volunteers to join the separatists.[204] Some separatists have flown the black-yellow-white Russian imperial flag,[198] such as the Sparta Battalion. In 2014, volunteers from the National Liberation Movement joined the Donetsk People's Republic People's Militia bearing portraits of Tsar Nicholas II.[200] The national flag of the Soviet Union is also commonly displayed at official events, parades, and celebrations in the DPR.[141]
Other Russian nationalist volunteers involved in separatist militias included members of the Eurasian Youth Union, and of banned groups such as the Slavic Union and Movement Against Illegal Immigration.[201] Another Russian separatist paramilitary unit, the Interbrigades, is made up of activists from the National Bolshevik (Nazbol) group Other Russia.[198] An article in Dissent noted that "despite their neo-Stalinist paraphernalia, many of the Russian-speaking nationalists Russia supports in the Donbass are just as right-wing as their counterparts from the Azov Battalion".[207]
In July 2015, the head of the Donetsk People's Republic, Alexander Zakharchenko, said at a press conference that he respected Ukraine's far-right party Right Sector "when they beat up the gays in Kyiv and when they tried to depose Poroshenko".[208]
While far-right activists played a part in the early days of the conflict, their importance was often exaggerated, and their importance on both sides of the conflict declined over time. The political climate in Donetsk further pushed far-right groups into the margins.[198]
In April 2022, news outlets noted that a video posted on Donetsk People's Republic's website showed Denis Pushilin awarding a medal to Lieutenant Roman Vorobyov (Somalia Battalion) while Vorobyov was wearing patches affiliated with neo-Nazism: the Totenkopf used by the 3rd SS Panzer Division, and the valknut. However, the video did not show Vorobyov getting his medal when it was posted on Pushilin's website.[209][210]
International status
The Donetsk People's Republic (DPR) initially sought recognition as a sovereign state following its declaration of independence in April 2014. Subsequently, the DPR willingly acceded to the Russian Federation as a Russian federal subject in September–October 2022, effectively ceasing to exist as a sovereign state in any capacity and revoking its status as such in the eyes of the international community. The DPR claims direct succession to Ukraine's Donetsk Oblast.
From 2014 to 2022, Ukraine, the United Nations, and most of the international community regarded the DPR as an illegal entity occupying a portion of Ukraine's Donetsk Oblast (see: International sanctions during the Russo-Ukrainian War). The Luhansk People's Republic (LPR), which had a similar backstory, was regarded in the exact same way. Crimea's status was treated slightly differently since Russia annexed that territory immediately after its declaration of independence in March 2014.
Up until February 2022, Russia did not recognise the DPR, although it maintained informal relations with the DPR. On 21 February 2022, Russia officially recognised the DPR and the LPR at the same time,[211] marking a major escalation in the 2021–2022 diplomatic crisis between Russia and Ukraine. Three days later, on 24 February 2022, Russia launched a full-scale invasion of the entire country of Ukraine, partially under the pretext of protecting the DPR and the LPR. The war had wide-reaching repercussions for Ukraine, Russia, and the international community as a whole (see: War crimes, Humanitarian impact, Environmental impact, Economic impact, and Ukrainian cultural heritage). In September 2022, Russia made moves to consolidate the territories that it had occupied in Ukraine, including Donetsk, Kherson, Luhansk, and Zaporizhzhia Oblasts. Russia officially annexed these four territories in September–October 2022.
Between February 2022 and October 2022, in addition to receiving Russian recognition, the DPR was recognised by North Korea (13 July 2022)[212] and Syria (29 June 2022).[213][214] This means that three United Nations member states recognised the DPR in total throughout its period of claimed independence. The DPR was also recognised by three other breakaway entities: the LPR, South Ossetia (19 June 2014),[215] and Abkhazia (25 February 2022).[216]
Relations with Ukraine
The Ukrainian government passed the "Law on the special status of Donbas" on 16 September 2014, which designated a special status within Ukraine on certain areas of Donetsk and Luhansk regions, in line with the Minsk agreements.[citation needed] The status lasted for three years, and then was extended annually several times.[217]
In January 2015, Ukraine declared the Russia-backed separatist republics in Donbas to be terrorist organizations.[218]
Relations with Russia before 2022
Russia has recognised identity documents, diplomas, birth, and marriage certificates and vehicle registration plates as issued by the DPR and the LPR since 18 February 2017,[219] enabling people living in DPR-controlled territories to travel, work, or study in Russia.[219] According to the decree, it was signed "to protect human rights and freedoms" in accordance with "the widely recognised principles of international humanitarian law".[220]
On February 21, 2022, Russian President Vladimir Putin signed agreements on friendship, cooperation, and assistance with DPR and the LPR, coinciding with Russia's official recognition of the two quasi-states.[211] The Russian State Duma had approved a draft resolution appealing for him to recognize both quasi-states on 15 February.[221] Shortly afterwards, Abkhazia also recognized the independence of the DPR.
Relations with extremist groups
According to the Kharkiv Human Rights Protection Group, a number of European politicians from extreme-right and extreme-left have received all-expenses-paid trips to the Donetsk People's Republic.[222]
Far-right
As well as Russian far-right groups (see #Right-wing nationalism), the DPR has cultivated relations with other European far-right groups and activists. The Lansing Institute for Global Threats and Democracies Studies acquired a memorandum of cooperation between the DPR and the far-right Russian Imperial Movement, which trains foreign volunteers; including members of the neo-Nazi Atomwaffen Division and Der Dritte Weg.[223][224][225][226][227] Anton Shekhovtsov, an expert on far-right movements in Russia and abroad, reported in 2014 that Polish neo-fascist group "Falanga", Italian far-right group "Millennium" and French Eurasianists had joined the Donbas separatists.[228][229][230] Members of Serbian Action have also joined the Donbas separatists.[231]
According to Italian newspaper la Repubblica, well-known Italian neo-fascist Andrea Palmeri (former member of the far-right New Force party) has been fighting for the DPR since 2014, and was hailed by DPR leader Gubarev as a "real fascist".[232] Other far-right activists with links to the DPR include French far-right MEP Jean-Luc Schaffhauser, Italian nationalist Alessandro Musolino, German neo-Nazi journalist Manuel Ochsenreiter, and Emmanuel Leroy, a far-right adviser to Marine Le Pen, former leader of the National Rally.[233][234]
Finnish neo-Nazis have been recruited for pro-Russian forces by local far-right pro-Russian parties.[235][236][237][238][239] In addition to recruiting, Janus Putkonen also runs the Russian-funded DONi (Donbass International News Agency) and MV-media, which publish pro-Russian propaganda about the DPR.[240][241]
Far-left
The DPR has also cultivated relations with various far-left groups. A small number of Spanish socialists travelled to Ukraine to fight for the separatists, with some explaining they were "repaying the favour" to Russia for the USSR's support to Republicans during the Spanish Civil War.[242] Spanish fighters founded the 'Carlos Palomino International Brigade', which flew the flag of the Second Spanish Republic. In 2015, it reportedly had less than ten members, and was later disbanded.[243]
A female member of the Israeli Communist Party also reportedly fought for the separatists in 2015.[244] Other examples of far-left groups fighting for the separatists were the 'DKO' (Volunteer Communist Unit) and the Interunit, which has been inactive since 2017.[245][246]
The Italian communist ska punk group Banda Bassotti has also been active in support of the DPR and has organized trips to Donetsk, one of which saw the participation of Eleonora Forenza, a member of the European Parliament for the Communist Refoundation Party.[247] Andrej Hunko, a member of the German parliament for the far-left party Die Linke, also travelled to Donetsk to support the separatists.[248]
Economy
The DPR has its own central bank, the Donetsk Republican Bank. The republic's economy is frequently described as dependent on contraband and gunrunning,[249] with some labelling it a mafia state. Joining DPR military formations or its civil services has become one of the few guarantees for a stable income in the DPR.[143]
By late October 2014, many banks and other businesses in the DPR were shut, and people were often left without social benefits payments.[179] Sources (who declined to be identified, citing security concerns) inside the DPR administration have told Bloomberg News that Russia transfers 2.5 billion Russian rubles ($37 million) for pensions every month.[250] By mid-February 2016 Russia had sent 48 humanitarian convoys to rebel-held territory that were said to have delivered more than 58,000 tons of cargo including food, medicines, construction materials, diesel generators and fuel and lubricants.[251] President Poroshenko called this a "flagrant violation of international law" and Valentyn Nalyvaychenko said it was a "direct invasion".[252]
Reuters in late October 2014 reported long lines at soup kitchens.[179] In the same month in at least one factory, workers no longer received wages, only food rations.[253]
By June 2015, due to logistical and transport problems, prices in DPR-controlled territory are significantly higher than in territory controlled by Ukraine.[143] This led to an increase of supplies (of more expensive products and those of lower quality) from Russia.[143] Mines and heavy-industry facilities damaged by shelling were forced to close, undermining the wider chain of economic ties in the region.[253] Three industrial facilities were under DPR "temporary management" by late October 2014.[253] By early June 2015, 80% of companies physically located in the Donetsk People's Republic had re-registered on territory under Ukrainian control.[249]
The new ruling elites of the DPR have displaced the previous oligarchic structures in the region.[254] The new powerholders expropriated profitable businesses. For instance, Rinat Akhmetov lost control over his assets in the region after they were nationalised. Under Russia's guidance, the republic set up trade and production monopolies through which the trade in coal and steel is organised. Lacking private banks, its own currency, and direct access to the Black Sea, DPR's survival depends exclusively on Russia's economic support and trade through the common border.[255]
A DPR official often promised financial support from Russia without giving specific details.[179] Prime Minister Aleksandr Zakharchenko in late October 2014 stated that "We have the Russian Federation's agreement in principle on granting us special conditions on gas (deliveries)".[179] Zakharchenko also claimed that "And, finally, we managed to link up with the financial and banking structure of the Russian Federation".[179] When Reuters tried to get more details from a source close to Zakharchenko the only reply was "Money likes silence".[179] Early October 2014 Zakharchenko stated, "The economy will be complete, if possible, oriented towards the Russian market. We consider Russia our strategic partner". According to Zakharchenko this would "secure our economy from impacts from outside, including from Ukraine".[256] According to Yury Makohon, from the Ukrainian National Institute for Strategic Studies, "Trade volume between Russia and Donetsk Oblast has seen a massive slump since the beginning of 2014".[257] Since Russia did not recognise the legal status of the self-proclaimed republic, all the trade it did with it was on the basis of Ukrainian law.[249]
DPR authorities have created a multi-currency zone in which both the rouble (Russia's currency) and the hryvnia (Ukraine's currency) can be used, and also the Euro and U.S. Dollar.[143][256] Cash shortages are widespread and, due to a lack of roubles, the hryvnia is the most-used currency.[143] According to Ukraine's security services in May 2016 alone the Russian government has passed US$19 million in cash to fund the DPR administration as well as 35,000 blank Russian passports.[258]
Since late February 2015, DPR-controlled territories receive their natural gas directly from Russia.[259] According to Russia, Ukraine should pay for these deliveries; Ukraine claims it does not receive payments for the supplies from DPR-controlled territory.[259][260] On 2 July 2015, Ukrainian Energy Minister Volodymyr Demchyshyn announced that he "did not expect" that Ukraine would supply natural gas to territory controlled by separatist troops in the 2015–2016 heating season.[261] Since 25 November 2015 Ukraine has halted all its imports of (and payments for) natural gas from Russia.[262]
The DPR set up its own mobile network operator called Feniks, which was to be fully operational by the end of the summer of 2015.[263] On 5 February 2015, Kyivstar claimed that Feniks illegally used equipment that they officially gave up in territories controlled by pro-Russian separatists.[263] On 18 April 2015, Prime Minister Zakharchenko issued a decree stating that all equipment given up by Kyivstar fell under the control of the separatists in order to "meet the needs of the population in the communication services".[263] The SIM cards of Feniks display the slogan "Connection for the victory".[264]
In mid-March 2017, Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko signed a temporary ban on the movement of goods to and from territory controlled by DPR and LPR. Ukraine has not bought coal from the Donets Black Coal Basin since then.[265]
Anthracite mines under DPR control reportedly supply coal to Poland through Russian shell companies to disguise its real origin.[266]
According to Ukrainian and Russian media, the coal export company Vneshtorgservis, owned by Serhiy Kurchenko, owes massive debts to coal mines located in separatist-controlled territory and other local companies.[267]
Sergey Zdrilyuk ("Abwehr"), former deputy of DPR militia, stated in an interview in 2020 that large-scale disassembly of mining equipment for scrap metal and other forms of looting took place routinely during Igor Girkin's time as a militia commander, and that Girkin took significant amounts of money with him to Moscow. Militia groups such as "Vostok" and "Oplot" as well as various "Cossack formations", were involved in looting on systematic basis.[268][269]
Human rights
An early March 2016 United Nations OHCHR report stated that people that lived in separatist-controlled areas were experiencing "complete absence of rule of law, reports of arbitrary detention, torture and incommunicado detention, and no access to real redress mechanisms".[270]
Freedom House evaluates the eastern Donbas territories controlled by the DPR and LPR as "not free", scoring 4 out of 100 in its 2022 Freedom in the World index, noting issues with severe political and media repression, numerous reports of torture, and arbitrary detention.[271] The Guardian noted on 17 February 2022 that "Public opposition in the DPR is virtually non-existent."[255]
War crimes
An 18 November 2014 United Nations report on eastern Ukraine stated that the DPR was in a state of "total breakdown of law and order".[272] The report noted "cases of serious human rights abuses by the armed groups continued to be reported, including torture, arbitrary and incommunicado detention, summary executions, forced labour, sexual violence, as well as the destruction and illegal seizure of property may amount to crimes against humanity".[272] The November report also stated "the HRMMU continued to receive allegations of sexual and gender-based violence in the eastern regions. In one reported incident, members of the pro-Russian Vostok Battalion "arrested" a woman for violating a curfew and beat her with metal sticks for three hours. The woman was also raped by several pro-Russian rebels from the battalion. The report also states that the UN mission "continued to receive reports of torture and ill-treatment by the Ukrainian law enforcement agencies and volunteer battalions and by the (pro-Russian separatist) armed groups, including beating, death threats, cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment, and lack of access to medical assistance".[273] In a 15 December 2014 press conference in Kyiv, UN Assistant Secretary-General for human rights Ivan Šimonović stated that the majority of human rights violations were committed in areas controlled by pro-Russian rebels.[274]
The United Nations report also accused the Ukrainian Army and Ukrainian (volunteer) territorial defence battalions, including the Azov Battalion,[275][276] of human rights abuses such as illegal detention, torture and ill-treatment of DPR and LPR supporters, noting official denials.[272][277] Amnesty International reported on 24 December 2014 that pro-government volunteer battalions were blocking Ukrainian aid convoys from entering separatist-controlled territory.[278]
On 24 July, Human Rights Watch accused the pro-Russian fighters of not taking measures to avoid encamping in densely populated civilian areas."[279][280] It also accused Ukrainian government forces and pro-government volunteer battalions of indiscriminate attacks on civilian areas, stating that "The use of indiscriminate rockets in populated areas violates international humanitarian law, or the laws of war, and may amount to war crimes."[279][280]
A report by the OHCHR Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights that was released on 2 March 2015 described media postings and online videos which indicated that the pro-Russian armed groups of the DPR carried out "summary, extrajudicial or arbitrary executions" of captured Ukrainian soldiers. In one incident, corpses of Ukrainian servicemen were found with "their hands tied with white electrical cable" after the pro-Russian rebel groups captured Donetsk International Airport. In January a DPR leader claimed that the rebel forces were detaining up to five "subversives" between the ages of 18 and 35 per day. A number of captured prisoners of war were forced to march in Donetsk while being assaulted by rebel soldiers and onlookers. The report also said that Ukrainian law enforcement agencies had engaged in a "pattern of enforced disappearances, secret detention and ill-treatment" of people suspected of "separatism" and "terrorism".[281] The report also mentions videos of members of one particular pro-Russian unit talking about running a torture facility in the basement of a Luhansk library. The head of the unit in question was the pro-Russian separatist commander Aleksandr Biednov, known as "Batman" (who was later killed) and the "head" of the torture chamber was a rebel called "Maniac" who "allegedly used a hammer to torture prisoners and surgery kit to scare and extract confessions from prisoners".[281][282]
In September 2015, OSCE published a report on the testimonies of victims held in places of illegal detention in Donbas.[283] In December 2015, a team led by Małgorzata Gosiewska published a comprehensive report on war crimes in Donbas.[284]
Allegations of anti-semitism
Alleged members of the Donetsk Republic carrying the flag of the Russian Federation,[285] passed out a leaflet to Jews that informed all Jews over the age of 16 that they would have to report to the Commissioner for Nationalities in the Donetsk Regional Administration building and register their property and religion. It also claimed that Jews would be charged a $50 'registration fee'.[286] If they did not comply, they would have their citizenship revoked, face 'forceful expulsion' and see their assets confiscated. The leaflet stated the purpose of registration was because "Jewish community of Ukraine supported Bandera Junta," and "oppose the pro-Slavic People's Republic of Donetsk".[285] The authenticity of the leaflet could not be independently verified.[287] The New York Times, Haaretz, and The New Republic said the fliers were "most likely a hoax".[288][289][290] France 24 also reported on the questionable authenticity of the leaflets.[291] According to Efraim Zuroff of the Simon Wiesenthal Center, the leaflets looked like some sort of provocation, and an attempt to paint the pro-Russian forces as anti-semitic.[292] The chief rabbi of Donetsk Pinchas Vishedski stated that the flyer was a fake meant to discredit the self-proclaimed republic,[293] and saying that anti-Semitic incidents in eastern Ukraine are "rare, unlike in Kyiv and western Ukraine"[294] and believes the men were 'trying to use the Jewish community in Donetsk as an instrument in the conflict;'[295] however, he also called the DPR Press Secretary Aleksander Kriakov "the most famous anti-Semite in the region" and questioned DPR's decision to appoint him.[296]
Religion
Religion in Donbas (Donetsk + Luhansk) (2016)[297]
At first the DPR adopted a constitution which stated that the Russian Orthodox Church of the Moscow Patriarchate was the official religion of the self-declared state.[298][299] This was changed with the promulgation of a law "on freedom of conscience and religious organisation" in November 2015, backed by three deputies professing Rodnovery (Slavic native faith), whose members organised the Svarozhich Battalion (of the Vostok Brigade) and the Rusich Company.[300][301] The new law caused the dissatisfaction of Metropolitan Hilarion of Donetsk and Mariupol of the Moscow Patriarchate church.[302]
Donetsk separatists consider Christian denominations such as the Ukrainian Orthodox Church – Kyiv Patriarchate, Ukrainian Autocephalous Orthodox Church, Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church and wider Roman Catholic Church, and Protestantism, as all being anti-Russian and see them as obstacles in the path of the separatist goal of uniting the region with Russia.[299]
Romani people
Hundreds of Romani families fled Donbas in 2014.[303] The News of Donbas reported that members of the Donbas People's Militia engaged in assaults and robbery on the Romani (also known as gypsies) population of Sloviansk. The armed separatists beat women and children, looted homes, and carried off the stolen goods in trucks, according to eyewitnesses.[304][better source needed][305][306][307] Romani fled en masse to live with relatives in other parts of the country, fearing ethnic cleansing, displacement and murder. Some men who decided to remain formed militia groups to protect their families and homes.[306] DPR Mayor Ponomarev said the attacks were only against gypsies who were involved in drug trafficking, and that he was 'cleaning the city from drugs.'[308] The US mission to the OSCE and Ukrainian Prime Minister Yatsenyuk condemned these actions.[304][305][309]
LGBT community
On 8 June 2014, it was reported that armed militants from the Donetsk Republic attacked a gay club in the capital of Donetsk, injuring several. Witnesses said 20 people forced their way into the club, stealing jewellery and other valuables; the assailants fired shots in the club, and several people were hurt.[310] In July 2015, a DPR Ministry of Information spokesperson stated "there are no gays in Donetsk, as they all went to Kyiv".[311] In 2015, the Deputy Minister of Political Affairs of the Donetsk People's Republic stated: "A culture of homosexuality is spreading ... This is why we must kill anyone who is involved in this."[312]
Prejudice against Ukrainian speakers
On 18 April 2014, Vyacheslav Ponomarev asked local residents of Sloviansk to report all suspicious persons, especially if they were speaking Ukrainian. He also promised that the local media would publish a phone number to report them.[313]
An 18 November 2014 United Nations report on eastern Ukraine stated that the DPR violated the rights of Ukrainian-speaking children because schools in rebel-controlled areas teach only in Russian and forbid pupils to speak Ukrainian.[272] In its May 2014 constitution, the DPR regime declared Russian and Ukrainian its official languages.[80] However, in March 2020, Russian was declared to be the sole official language of the DPR.[161]
Abductions
The Committee to Protect Journalists said that separatists had seized up to ten foreign reporters during the week following the shooting down of the Malaysian aircraft.[314] On 22 July 2014, armed men from the DPR abducted Ukrainian freelance journalist Anton Skiba as he arrived with a CNN crew at a hotel in Donetsk.[314] The DPR often counters such accusations by pointing towards non-governmental organisations, such as Amnesty International's reporting that pro-Ukrainian volunteer paramilitary battalions, such as the Aidar Battalion, Donbas Battalion, Azov Battalion often acted like "renegade gangs", and were implicated in torture, abductions, and summary executions.[278][315] Amnesty International and the (OHCHR) also raised similar concerns about Radical Party leader and Ukrainian MP Oleh Lyashko and his militia.[316]
Donetsk has also observed significant rise in violent crime (homicide, rape, including underage victims) under the control of separatist forces.[317] In July 2015 local authorities of Druzhkovka, previously occupied by separatist forces, exposed a previous torture site in one of the town's cellars.[318]
On 2 June 2017 the freelance journalist Stanislav Aseyev was abducted. Firstly the DPR "government" denied knowing his whereabouts but on 16 July, an agent of the DPR's Ministry of State Security confirmed that Aseyev was in their custody and that he was suspected of espionage. Independent media is not allowed to report from the DPR-controlled territory.[319] Amnesty International, the Committee to Protect Journalists, the European Federation of Journalists, Human Rights Watch, the Norwegian Helsinki Committee, the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, PEN International, Reporters Without Borders and the United States Mission to the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe have called for the immediate release of Aseyev.[320][321][322][323][324][325] He was released as part of a prison exchange and handed over to Ukrainian authorities on 29 December 2019.[326]
Sergey Zdrilyuk ("Abwehr"), former deputy of DPR militia, confirmed in 2020 that Igor Girkin personally executed prisoners of war he considered "traitors" or "spies".[268][269] This statement was first made in Girkin's interview earlier that year, although Girkin insisted the executions were part of his "military tribunal based on laws of war". Girkin also confessed that he was involved in the murder of Volodymyr Ivanovych Rybak, a representative of Horlivka who was abducted on 17 April 2014 after trying to raise a Ukrainian flag: "Naturally, Rybak, as a person who actively opposed the "militias", was an enemy in my eyes. And his death, probably, is to some extent also under my responsibility".[327]
Forced Passportization
According to a US study, Ukrainians in occupied territories who refuse Russian passports face threats, intimidation and possible detention or deportation.[328][329] In April 2022, Russia adopted a law that allows authorities to detain or deport residents without Russian passports. Starting July 2024, residents without Russian citizenship would be considered "foreigners" or "stateless". In June 2023, the head of the so-called "Donetsk People’s Republic" announced a planning group to study facilities for detaining residents without Russian passports for deportation.[328]
Education
By the start of the 2015–2016 school-year DPR's authorities had overhauled the curriculum.[330] Ukrainian language lessons were decreased from around eight hours a week to two hours; while the time devoted to Russian language and literature lessons were increased.[330] The history classes were changed to give greater emphasis to the history of Donbas.[330] The grading system was changed from (Ukraine's) 12-point scheme to the five-point grading system that is also used in Russia.[330] According to the director of a college in Donetsk "We give students the choice between the two but the Russian one is taken into greater account".[330] School graduates will receive a Russian certificate, allowing them to enter both local universities and institutions in Russia.[330]
In April 2016 DPR authorities designed "statehood awareness lessons" were introduced in schools (in territory controlled by them).[331]
Territorial control
| Name | Pop. | Raion | Held by | As of | More information |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andriivka | 71 | Bakhmut |  Russia[332] | 16 Sep 2024 | Recaptured by Russia between around 28 November – 1 December 2022.[333][334][335] Recaptured by  Ukraine between 14–15 September 2023.[336]Claimed by Russia on 23 May 2024.[337]Confirmed captured by Russia on 16 September 2024.[332] |
| Arkhanhelske | 285 | Pokrovsk | Russia[338] | 4 May 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 30 April – 3 May 2024.[339] Recaptured by Russia on 3 May 2024.[338] |
| Avdiivka | 31,940 | Pokrovsk | Russia[340][341] | 17 Feb 2024 | See Battle of Avdiivka (2017), Battle of Avdiivka (2022–2024) Captured by  Donetsk PR in mid-April 2014.Mostly recaptured by Ukraine 21 July 2014.Recaptured by Russia on 17 February 2024.[342] |
| Bakhmut | 72,310 | Bakhmut | Russia[343] | 23 May 2023 | See Battle of Artemivsk (2014), Battle of Bakhmut (2022-2023) Captured by Donetsk PR in April 2014.Recaptured by Ukraine on 6 July 2014.Recaptured by Russia on 20 May 2023.[344][345] |
| Bakhmutske | 612 | Bakhmut | Russia[346] | 27 Dec 2022 | Captured by Russia 27 December 2022 |
| Berdychi | 267 | Pokrovsk | Russia[347] | 28 Apr 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 28 February – 27 April 2024.[348][349][350] Recaptured by Russia between around 20–27 April 2024.[351][352][347] |
| Berestove | 1,278 | Bakhmut | Russia[353] | 28 Jul 2022 | Captured by Donetsk PR in July 2022. |
| Blahodatne | 564 | Volnovakha | Ukraine | 24 Sep 2023 | Captured by Russia/ DPR in 2022. Recaptured by Ukraine on 10 June 2023.[354] |
| Bohdanivka | 77 | Bakhmut | Russia[355] | 8 Apr 2024 | Contested by Russia between before 17 January – 8 April 2024.[356] Recaptured by Russia on 8 April 2024.[355] |
| Bohoiavlenka | 1,490 | Volnovakha | Russia[357] | 27 Oct 2024 | Contested by Russia on 26 October 2024.[358] Likely captured by Russia on 27 October 2024.[357] |
| Bohorodychne | 794 | Kramatorsk | Ukraine | 11 Sep 2022 | See Sloviansk offensive Captured by Russia 11 July 2022.[359]Recaptured by Ukraine 11 September 2022.[360][361] |
| Chasiv Yar | 12,557 | Bakhmut | Contested[362] | 19 May 2024 | See Battle of Chasiv Yar Pressured by Russia between 4 April – 17 May 2024.[363]Contested by Russia since 17 May 2024.[362] |
| Dalne | 403 | Pokrovsk | Contested[364] | 12 Nov 2024 | Contested by Russia since 11 November 2024.[364] |
| Debaltseve | 24,316 | Horlivka | Russia | 20 Feb 2015 | See Battle of Debaltseve (2015) Captured by Donetsk PR in mid-April 2014.Recaptured by Ukraine 29 July 2014.Recaptured by Donetsk PR 18 February 2015. |
| Dobropillia | 28,170 | Pokrovsk | Ukraine | 24 Feb 2022 | |
| Donetsk | 905,364 | Donetsk | Russia[365] | 22 Feb 2022 | See March 2022 Donetsk attack Captured by Donetsk PR 7 April 2014. |
| Druzhba | 1,860 | Bakhmut | Russia[366] | 5 Nov 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 18 June – 2 July 2024.[367][368] Contested by Russia between around 3 July – 4 November 2024.[369]Claimed captured by Russia on 31 August 2024.[370]Captured by Russia by 5 November 2024.[366] |
| Druzhkivka | 55,088 | Kramatorsk | Ukraine[371] | 4 May 2022 | |
| Halytsynivka | 1,111 | Pokrovsk | Russia[372] | 3 Sep 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 31 August – 2 September 2024.[373] Likely captured by Russia around 3 September 2024.[372] |
| Heorhiivka | 1,167 | Pokrovsk | Russia[374] | 14 Jun 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 15 January – 5 June 2024.[375] Recaptured by Russia between around 5–14 June 2024.[376][377][374] |
| Hirnyk | 10,357 | Pokrovsk | Russia[358] | 27 Oct 2024 | Claimed contested by Russian sources starting 18 September 2024.[378] Confirmed contested by Russia between around 26 September – 26 October 2024.[379]Captured by Russia on 27 October 2024.[358] |
| Horlivka | 241,106 | Horlivka | Russia[380] | 9 Mar 2022 | See Battle of Horlivka (2014) Captured by Donetsk PR in mid-April 2014. |
| Hostre | 557 | Pokrovsk | Russia[381] | 4 Oct 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 12 September – 2 October 2024.[382] Claimed captured by Russian sources on 22 September 2024.[383]Confirmed captured by Russia by 3 October 2024.[381] |
| Hrodivka | 2,299 | Pokrovsk | Russia[384] | 21 Oct 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 4–12 August 2024.[385] Contested by Russia between around 13 August – 20 October 2024.[386][387]Claimed captured by Russia on 7 October 2024.[388]Confirmed captured by Russia on 21 October 2024.[384] |
| Illinka | 440 | Pokrovsk | Russia[358] | 13 Nov 2024 | Contested by Russia between 7–12 November 2024.[389] Captured by Russia on 13 November 2024.[358] |
| Ilovaisk | 17,620 | Donetsk | Russia | 20 Feb 2015 | See Battle of Ilovaisk (2014) Captured by Donetsk PR in mid-April 2014.Recaptured by Ukraine 19 August 2014.Recaptured by Donetsk PR 1 September 2014. |
| Ivanivka | 669 | Pokrovsk | Russia[390] | 13 Aug 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 25–31 July 2024.[391][392] Contested by Russia between around 1–12 August 2024.[393][385][394]Captured by Russia around 13 August 2024.[390] |
| Ivanivske | 1,369 | Bakhmut | Russia[395][363] | 4 Apr 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 23 February – 23 March 2024.[396][397] Recaptured by Russia around 23 March 2024.[398][399][363] |
| Ivano-Daryivka | 23 | Bakhmut | Russia[400] | 19 Jul 2024 | Captured by Russia around 17 July 2024.[400] |
| Izmailivka | 199 | Pokrovsk | Russia[401] | 24 Oct 2024 | Captured by Russia on 23 October 2024.[401] |
| Kalynivka | 542 | Bakhmut | Contested[402] | 17 Jun 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 12–30 May 2024.[403] Contested by Russia since around 30 May 2024.[404][405][402] |
| Kalynove | 219 | Pokrovsk | Russia[406] | 27 Aug 2024 | Captured by Russia on 27 August 2024.[406] |
| Karlivka | 414 | Pokrovsk | Russia[373] | 30 Aug 2024 | Claimed contested by a Russian source starting 14 June 2024.[407] Contested by Russia between around 22 June – 29 August 2024.[408]Captured by Russia around 30 August 2024.[409][373] |
| Katerynivka | 778 | Pokrovsk | Russia[410] | 3 Nov 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 4 October – 2 November 2024.[411] Claimed captured by Russia on 29 October 2024.[412]Confirmed captured by Russia on 3 November 2024.[410] |
| Keramik | 339 | Pokrovsk | Russia[338] | 4 May 2024 | Pressured by Russia around 26 April 2024. Contested by Russia between around 27 April – early May 2024.[347]Fully recaptured by Russia between around 28 April – 3 May 2024.[352][347][338] |
| Khromove | 833 | Bakhmut | Russia | 31 Dec 2023 | Recaptured by Russia on 29 November 2023.[413][414] |
| Klishchiivka | 512 | Bakhmut | Russia[402] | 17 Jun 2024 | Captured by Russia on 19 January 2023. Recaptured by Ukraine between 17–22 September 2023.[415][416]Contested by Russia between around 19 – late May 2024.[417]Recaptured by Russia between around late May – 17 June 2024.[417][418][402] |
| Komyshivka | 365 | Pokrovsk | Russia[419] | 22 Aug 2024 | Captured by Russia around 21 August 2024.[419][420] |
| Kostiantynivka | 68,792 | Kramatorsk | Ukraine[421][422] | 10 Mar 2022 | Captured by Donetsk PR in mid-April 2014. Recaptured by Ukraine 7 July 2014. |
| Kostiantynivka | 1,293 | Pokrovsk | Russia[423] | 28 Aug 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 5 June – 23 July 2024.[376] Contested by Russia between around 24 July – 26 August 2024.[391]Likely captured by Russia on 27 August 2024.[423] |
| Kramatorsk | 150,084 | Kramatorsk | Ukraine[371] | 4 May 2022 | See Battle of Kramatorsk (2014), Kramatorsk railway station attack Captured by Donetsk PR 12 April 2014.Recaptured by Ukraine 5 July 2014. |
| Krasna Hora | 584 | Bakhmut | Russia[424] | 11 Feb 2023 | Recaptured by Russia on 11 February 2023. |
| Krasnohorivka | 14,917 | Pokrovsk | Russia[425][381] | 10 Sep 2024 | See Battle of Krasnohorivka Contested by Russia between 8 April – 8 September 2024.[426]Captured by Russia on 9 September 2024.[425] |
| Krasnohorivka (village) | 526 | Pokrovsk | Russia[427] | 17 Mar 2023 | |
| Krutyi Yar | 107 | Pokrovsk | Russia[428] | 29 Sep 2024 | Recaptured by Russia around 29 September 2024.[428] |
| Kurakhove | 18,220 | Pokrovsk | Contested[429] | 30 Oct 2024 | See Battle of Kurakhove Pressured by Russia between around 3–28 October 2024.[381]Contested by Russia since 29 October 2024.[429] |
| Kurakhivka | 2,600 | Pokrovsk | Russia[430] | 31 Oct 2024 | Contested by Russia on 30 October 2024.[429] Claimed captured by Russian sources on 30 October 2024.[429]Confirmed captured by Russia on 31 October 2024.[430] |
| Lastochkyne | 617 | Pokrovsk | Russia[431] | 24 Feb 2024 | Recaptured by Russia on 24 February 2024.[431] |
| Lyman | 20,469 | Kramatorsk | Ukraine[432][433] | 1 Oct 2022 | See Battle of Krasnyi Lyman (2014), Battle of Lyman (September–October 2022) Captured by Donetsk PR in mid-April 2014.Recaptured by Ukraine 5 June 2014.Recaptured by Russia/ DPR 27 May 2022.[434][435][436][437]Recaptured by Ukraine on 1 October 2022.[432][433][438] |
| Lozuvatske | 17 | Pokrovsk | Russia[439] | 26 Jul 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 16–25 July 2024.[440] Captured by Russia around 26 July 2024.[439] |
| Lysivka | 799 | Pokrovsk | Contested[441] | 3 Oct 2024 | Contested by Russia since around 11 September 2024.[442] Claimed captured by Russian sources on 12 September 2024.[382]Visually confirmed contested since 2 October 2024.[441] |
| Makarivka | 258 | Volnovakha | Ukraine | 24 Sep 2023 | Captured by Russia/ DPR in 2022. Recaptured by Ukraine between 13–14 June 2023.[443] |
| Makiivka | 340,337 | Donetsk | Russia[380] | 9 Mar 2022 | Captured by Donetsk PR on 13 April 2014. |
| Maksymilianivka | 2,171 | Pokrovsk | Russia[384] | 21 Oct 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 14 June – 29 June 2024.[374] Contested by Russia between around 29 June – 19 October 2024.[444]Claimed captured by Russia on 17 October 2024.[445]Confirmed captured by Russia on 20 October 2024.[384] |
| Maksymivka | 793 | Volnovakha | Russia[410] | 2 Nov 2024 | Captured by Russia on 2 November 2024.[410] |
| Mezhove | 36 | Pokrovsk | Russia[419] | 22 Aug 2024 | Captured by Russia around 19 August 2024.[419][446] |
| Marinka | 10,722 | Pokrovsk | Russia[447] | 25 Dec 2023 | See Battle of Marinka (2015), Battle of Marinka (2022–2023) Captured by Donetsk PR in mid-April 2014.Recaptured by Ukraine on 5 August 2014.Contested by Russia between around spring 2022 and 24 December 2023.[448][449]Recaptured by Russia on 24–25 December 2023.[450][447] |
| Mariupol | 431,859 | Mariupol | Russia[451] | 17 May 2022 | See Battle of Mariupol (2014), 2014 offensive, 2015 attack, Siege of Mariupol, Hospital airstrike, Theatre airstrike Partially captured by Donetsk PR 9 May 2014.Recaptured by Ukraine 13 June 2014Recaptured by Russia/ DPR on 16 May 2022.[451] |
| Mykhailivka | 1,269 | Pokrovsk | Russia[452] | 1 Sep 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 18–25 August 2024.[453] Contested by Russia between around 26–31 August 2024.[454][455]Likely captured by Russia around 1 September 2024.[452] |
| Mykolaivka | 101 | Pokrovsk | Russia[358] | 16 Oct 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 24 September – 9 October 2024.[379] Captured by Russia around 10 October 2024.[358] |
| Mykolaivka | 805 | Pokrovsk | Russia[456] | 24 Aug 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 14–16 August 2024.[387] Claimed captured by Russian sources on 16 August 2024.[457]Captured by Russia between around 17–23 August 2024.[458][456] |
| Myrnohrad | 46,098 | Pokrovsk | Ukraine | 29 Aug 2024 | Pressured by Russia since around 29 August 2024.[455] |
| Neskuchne | 644 | Volnovakha | Ukraine | 24 Sep 2023 | Captured by Russia/ DPR in Spring 2022. Recaptured by Ukraine on 10 June 2023.[354] |
| Nelipivka | 977 | Bakhmut | Contested[459] | 4 Nov 2024 | Claimed contested by Russia starting 19 August 2024.[460] Confirmed contested by Russia between around 5 September – October 2024.[461]Claimed captured by Russia on 30 September 2024.[383][462]Captured by Russia by 18 October 2024.[463]Contested by Ukraine since around 4 November 2024.[459] |
| Netailove | 1,141 | Pokrovsk | Russia[464] | 21 May 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 16–27 April 2024.[465] Contested by Russia between around 28 April – 18 May 2024.[347][466]Recaptured by Russia between around 18–20 May 2024.[417][464] |
| Nevelske | 283 | Pokrovsk | Russia[467] | 10 Aug 2024 | Recaptured by Russia around 12 March 2024.[468][469] Recaptured by Ukraine before 4 May 2024.[470]Pressured by Russia between around 14 May – 11 June 2024.[471]Contested by Russia between around 12 June – 8 August 2024.[472]Recaptured by Russia on 9 August 2024.[467] |
| New York | 9,735 | Bakhmut | Russia[473] | 7 Oct 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 18 June – 2 July 2024.[367][368] Contested by Russia between around 3 July – September 2024.[474]Claimed captured by Russian sources on 18 August 2024.[453][460]Captured by Russia in September 2024.[473] |
| Novobakhmutivka | 191 | Pokrovsk | Russia[475] | 25 Apr 2024 | Contested by Russia between 23–24 April 2024.[476] Recaptured by Russia on 24 April 2024.[477][478][475] |
| Novohrodivka | 14,037 | Pokrovsk | Russia[479][480] | 27 Aug 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 14–21 August 2024.[387][481] [460] Contested by Russia between around 22–26 August 2024.[482][483]Captured by Russia around 27 August 2024.[479][480][484][485] |
| Novokalynove | 521 | Pokrovsk | Russia[352] | 27 Apr 2024 | Contested by Russia between 16–27 April 2024.[486][487] Recaptured by Russia around 27 April 2024.[352] |
| Novoluhanske | 3,700 | Bakhmut | Russia[488] | 26 May 2022 | Captured along with Vuhlehirske Power Plant by Russia/ DPR on 26 July 2022[489] |
| Novomaiorske | 551 | Volnovakha | Russia[490] | 10 Apr 2022 | |
| Novomykhailivka | 1,439 | Pokrovsk | Russia[476] | 23 Apr 2024 | Contested by Russia between around 6 February – 21 April 2024.[491] Captured by Russia around 22 April 2024.[492][493][476] |
| Novooleksandrivka | 693 | Pokrovsk | Russia[494] | 11 Jun 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 6 May – 7 June 2024.[495][496][418] Contested by Russia between around 8–10 June 2024.[497]Recaptured by Russia around 10 June 2024.[494] |
| Novopokrovske | 64 | Pokrovsk | Russia[498] | 13 Jun 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 7 May – 9 June 2024.[499] Contested by Russia between around 10–12 June 2024.[500]Recaptured by Russia between 12–13 June 2024.[472][498] |
| Novosadove | 32 | Kramatorsk | Russia[358] | 22 Oct 2024 | Recaptured by Russia on 22 October 2024.[358] |
| Novoselivka | 541 | Pokrovsk | Russia | 14 May 2022 | |
| Novoselivka Persha | 942 | Pokrovsk | Russia[501] | 29 Jul 2024 | Pressured by Russia between around 12 June – 10 July 2024.[472] Contested by Russia between around 11–28 July 2024.[502]Captured by Russia around 29 July 2024.[501] |
| Novosilka | 104 | Volnovakha | Ukraine[503] | 4 May 2022 | |
| Novotroitske | 6,445 | Volnovakha | Russia[504][505] | 6 May 2022 | Captured by Donetsk PR 11 March 2022. |
| Novoukrainka | 1,523 | Volnovakha | Russia[358] | 29 Oct 2024 | Contested by Russia between 26–28 October 2024.[358] Captured by Russia on 29 October 2024.[358] |
| Novozhelanne | 274 | Pokrovsk | Russia[460
|