| Season | Position | Mythical First Team | Mythical Second Team | Ref. |
| Players | Teams | Players | Teams |
| 1975 | Guard | Francis Arnaiz* | Toyota Comets | The Mythical Second Team was first awarded in 1984. |
| Guard | Atoy Co* | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Center | Manny Paner* | Royal Tru-Orangemen |
| Forward | Ernesto Estrada | Royal Tru-Orangemen |
| Forward | Bogs Adornado* | Crispa Redmanizers |
| 1976 | Guard | Francis Arnaiz* (2) | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Guard | Atoy Co (2)* | Crispa Denims |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Forward | Philip Cezar* | Crispa Denims |
| Forward | Bogs Adornado* (2) | Crispa Denims |
| 1977 | Guard | Robert Jaworski* | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Guard | Atoy Co* (3) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* (2) | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Forward | Freddie Hubalde* | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Forward | Jun Papa | Mariwasa Panthers |
| 1978 | Guard | Robert Jaworski* (2) | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Guard | Lim Eng Beng* | U/Tex Wranglers |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* (3) | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Forward | Freddie Hubalde* (2) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Forward | Philip Cezar* (2) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| 1979 | Guard | Robert Jaworski* (3) | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Guard | Atoy Co* (4) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* (4) | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Forward | Philip Cezar* (3) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Forward | Arnie Tuadles | Toyota Tamaraws |
| 1980 | Guard | Robert Jaworski* (4) | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Guard | Atoy Co* (5) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* (5) | Toyota Tamaraws |
| Forward | Philip Cezar* (4) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Forward | Bogs Adornado* (3) | U/Tex Wranglers |
| 1981 | Guard | Robert Jaworski* (5) | Toyota Super Diesels |
| Guard | Atoy Co* (6) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* (6) | Toyota Super Diesels |
| Forward | Philip Cezar* (5) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Forward | Bogs Adornado* (4) | U-Tex Wranglers |
| 1982 | Guard | Francis Arnaiz* (3) | Toyota Super Corollas |
| Guard | Atoy Co* (7) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* (7) | Toyota Super Corollas |
| Forward | Bogs Adornado* (5) | U/Tex Wranglers |
| Forward | Abe King | Toyota Super Corollas |
| 1983 | Guard | Ricardo Brown* | Great Taste Coffee Makers |
| Guard | Atoy Co* (8) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Center | Abet Guidaben* | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Forward | Philip Cezar* (6) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Forward | Bogs Adornado* (6) | Great Taste Coffee Makers |
| 1984 | Guard | Ricardo Brown* (2) | Great Taste Coffee Makers | Willie Pearson | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Guard | Atoy Co* (9) | Crispa Redmanizers | Bernie Fabiosa | Crispa Redmanizers |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* (8) | Beer Hausen Brewmasters | Terry Saldaña | Gilbey's Gin Tonics |
| Forward | Abet Guidaben* (2) | Crispa Redmanizers | Bogs Adornado* (7) | Great Taste Coffee Makers |
| Forward | Manny Victorino | Great Taste Coffee Makers | Philip Cezar* (7) | Crispa Redmanizers |
| 1985 | Guard | Ricardo Brown* (3) | Great Taste Coffee Makers | Robert Jaworski* (6) | Ginebra San Miguel |
| Guard | Willie Pearson (2) | Great Taste Coffee Makers | Willie Generalao | Tanduay Rhum Makers |
| Center | Abet Guidaben* (3) | Manila Beer Brewmasters | Ramon Fernandez* (9) | Tanduay Rhum Makers |
| Forward | Manny Victorino (2) | Great Taste Coffee Makers | Philip Cezar* (8) | Shell Azodrin Bugbusters |
| Forward | Bogs Adornado* (8) | Shell Azodrin Bugbusters | Abe King (2) | Great Taste Coffee Makers |
| 1986 | Guard | Ricardo Brown* (4) | Great Taste Coffee Makers | Chito Loyzaga | Ginebra San Miguel |
| Guard | Robert Jaworski* (7) | Ginebra San Miguel | Padim Israel | Tanduay Rhum Makers |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* (10) | Tanduay Rhum Makers | Terry Saldaña (2) | Ginebra San Miguel |
| Forward | Manny Victorino (3) | Great Taste Coffee Makers | JB Yango | Tanduay Rhum Makers |
| Forward | Freddie Hubalde* (3) | Tanduay Rhum Makers | Dondon Ampalayo | Ginebra San Miguel |
| 1987 | Guard | Hector Calma* | San Miguel Beermen | Ricardo Brown* (5) | Great Taste Coffee Makers |
| Guard | Philip Cezar* (9) | Great Taste Coffee Makers | Arnie Tuadles (2) | Great Taste Coffee Makers |
| Center | Abet Guidaben* (4) | San Miguel Beermen | Ramon Fernandez* (11) | Tanduay Rhum Makers |
| Forward | Elpidio Villamin | Hills Bros. Coffee Kings | Bernardo Carpio | Great Taste Coffee Makers |
| Forward | Allan Caidic* | Great Taste Coffee Makers | Ricky Relosa | Hills Bros. Coffee Kings |
| 1988 | Guard | Ricardo Brown* (6) | San Miguel Beermen | Robert Jaworski* (8) | Añejo Rum 65ers |
| Guard | Hector Calma* (2) | San Miguel Beermen | Jojo Lastimosa | Purefoods Hotdogs |
| Center | Abet Guidaben* (5) | Purefoods Hotdogs | Jerry Codiñera | Purefoods Hotdogs |
| Forward | Ramon Fernandez* (12) | San Miguel Beermen | Dondon Ampalayo (2) | Añejo Rum 65ers |
| Forward | Allan Caidic* (2) | Presto Ice Cream Makers | Elpidio Villamin (2) | Alaska Milkmen |
| 1989 | Guard | Hector Calma* (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Elmer Reyes | San Miguel Beermen |
| Guard | Allan Caidic* (3) | Presto Tivolis | Ronnie Magsanoc* | Formula Shell Zoom Masters |
| Center | Benjie Paras* | Formula Shell Zoom Masters | Jerry Codiñera (2) | Purefoods Hotdogs |
| Forward | Ramon Fernandez* (13) | San Miguel Beermen | Alvin Teng | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio* | Purefoods Hotdogs | Paul Alvarez | Alaska Milkmen |
| 1990 | Guard | Ronnie Magsanoc* (2) | Formula Shell Zoom Masters | Samboy Lim* | San Miguel Beermen |
| Guard | Paul Alvarez (2) | Alaska Milkmen | Rudy Distrito | Añejo Rum 65ers |
| Center | Benjie Paras* (2) | Formula Shell Zoom Masters | Ramon Fernandez* (14) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Allan Caidic* (4) | Presto Tivolis | Elpidio Villamin (3) | Alaska Milkmen |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio* (2) | Purefoods Hotdogs | Rey Cuenco | Añejo Rum 65ers |
| 1991 | Guard | Jojo Lastimosa (2) | Alaska Milkmen | Ronnie Magsanoc* (3) | Shell Rimula X |
| Guard | Allan Caidic* (5) | Tivoli Milkmasters | Ato Agustin | San Miguel Beermen |
| Center | Benjie Paras* (3) | Shell Rimula X | Jerry Codiñera (3) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio* (3) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Alvin Teng (2) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Ramon Fernandez* (15) | San Miguel Beermen | Elpidio Villamin (4) | Diet Sarsi Sizzlers |
| 1992 | Guard | Ato Agustin (2) | San Miguel Beermen | Ronnie Magsanoc* (4) | Shell Rimula X |
| Guard | Al Solis | Swift Mighty Meaties | Elmer Cabahug | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs |
| Center | Ramon Fernandez* (16) | San Miguel Beermen | Benjie Paras* (4) | Shell Rimula X |
| Forward | Nelson Asaytono | Swift Mighty Meaties | Jerry Codiñera (4) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio* (4) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Alvin Teng (3) | San Miguel Beermen |
| 1993 | Guard | Ato Agustin (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Allan Caidic* (6) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Guard | Al Solis (2) | Swift Mighty Meaties | Samboy Lim* [2] | San Miguel Beermen |
| Center | Jerry Codiñera (5) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Jun Limpot | Sta. Lucia Realtors |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio* (5) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Vergel Meneses | Swift Mighty Meaties |
| Forward | Nelson Asaytono (2) | Swift Mighty Meaties | Alvin Teng (4) | San Miguel Beermen |
| 1994 | Guard | Johnny Abarrientos | Alaska Milkmen | Boybits Victoria | Swift Mighty Meaties |
| Guard | Ato Agustin (4) | San Miguel Beermen | Allan Caidic* (7) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Center | Jerry Codiñera (6) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Benjie Paras* (5) | Shell Rimula X |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio* (6) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Bong Hawkins | Alaska Milkmen |
| Forward | Vergel Meneses (2) | Swift Mighty Meaties | Nelson Asaytono (3) | Swift Mighty Meaties |
| 1995 | Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (2) | Alaska Milkmen | Boybits Victoria (2) | Sunkist Orange Juicers |
| Guard | Allan Caidic* (8) | San Miguel Beermen | Jojo Lastimosa (3) | Alaska Milkmen |
| Center | Benjie Paras* (6) | Formula Shell Gas Kings | Bonel Balingit | Sunkist Orange Juicers |
| Forward | Bong Hawkins (2) | Alaska Milkmen | Nelson Asaytono (4) | Sunkist Orange Juicers |
| Forward | Vergel Meneses (3) | Sunkist Orange Juicers | Alvin Patrimonio* (7) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs |
| 1996 | Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (3) | Alaska Milkmen | Bal David | Ginebra San Miguel |
| Guard | Jojo Lastimosa (4) | Alaska Milkmen | Jeffrey Cariaso | Alaska Milkmen |
| Center | Marlou Aquino | Ginebra San Miguel | Benjie Paras* (7) | Formula Shell Zoom Masters |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio* (8) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Noli Locsin | Ginebra San Miguel |
| Forward | Bong Hawkins (3) | Alaska Milkmen | Nelson Asaytono (5) | San Miguel Beermen |
| 1997 | Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (4) | Alaska Milkmen | Dindo Pumaren | Purefoods Carne Norte Beefies |
| Guard | Vince Hizon | Gordon's Gin Boars | Bong Ravena | Purefoods Carne Norte Beefies |
| Center | Marlou Aquino (2) | Gordon's Gin Boars | Jerry Codiñera (7) | Purefoods Carne Norte Beefies |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio* (9) | Purefoods Carne Norte Beefies | Noli Locsin (2) | Gordon's Gin Boars |
| Forward | Nelson Asaytono (6) | San Miguel Beermen | Jun Limpot (2) | Sta. Lucia Realtors |
| 1998 | Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (5) | Alaska Milkmen | Olsen Racela | San Miguel Beermen |
| Guard | Jojo Lastimosa (5) | Alaska Milkmen | Mike Mustre | San Miguel Beermen |
| Center | Jerry Codiñera (8) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Danny Ildefonso | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio (10) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Nelson Asaytono (7) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Kenneth Duremdes | Alaska Milkmen | Victor Pablo | Formula Shell Super Unleaded |
| 1999 | Guard | Johnny Abarrientos (6) | Alaska Milkmen | Olsen Racela (2) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Guard | Jeffrey Cariaso (2) | Mobiline Phone Pals | Jojo Lastimosa (6) | Alaska Milkmen |
| Center | Sonny Alvarado | Tanduay Rhum Masters | Danny Ildefonso (2) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Benjie Paras* (8) | Shell Velocity | Eric Menk | Tanduay Rhum Masters |
| Forward | Danny Seigle | San Miguel Beermen | Kenneth Duremdes (2) | Alaska Milkmen |
| 2000 | Guard | Olsen Racela (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Dindo Pumaren (2) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs |
| Guard | Kenneth Duremdes (3) | Alaska Milkmen | Jeffrey Cariaso (3) | Tanduay Rhum Masters |
| Center | Danny Ildefonso (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Marlou Aquino (3) | Sta. Lucia Realtors |
| Forward | Alvin Patrimonio* (11) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs | Bong Hawkins (4) | Alaska Milkmen |
| Forward | Danny Seigle (2) | San Miguel Beermen | Rudy Hatfield | Tanduay Rhum Masters |
| 2001 | Guard | Olsen Racela (4) | San Miguel Beermen | Noy Castillo | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs |
| Guard | Danny Seigle (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Kenneth Duremdes (4) | Alaska Aces |
| Center | Danny Ildefonso (4) | San Miguel Beermen | Davonn Harp | Batang Red Bull Thunder |
| Forward | Ali Peek | Alaska Aces | Nic Belasco | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Dennis Espino | Sta. Lucia Realtors | Rudy Hatfield (2) | Pop Cola Panthers |
| 2002 | Guard | Willie Miller | Batang Red Bull Thunder | Gilbert Demape | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals |
| Guard | Jeffrey Cariaso (4) | Coca-Cola Tigers | Rey Evangelista | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs |
| Center | Davonn Harp (2) | Batang Red Bull Thunder | Asi Taulava | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals |
| Forward | Victor Pablo (2) | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals | Nic Belasco (2) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Don Allado | Alaska Aces | Kerby Raymundo | Purefoods Tender Juicy Hotdogs |
| 2003 | Guard | Jimmy Alapag | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals | Johnny Abarrientos (7) | Coca-Cola Tigers |
| Guard | Jeffrey Cariaso (5) | Coca-Cola Tigers | John Arigo | Alaska Aces |
| Center | Asi Taulava (2) | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals | Marlou Aquino (4) | Sta. Lucia Realtors |
| Forward | Rudy Hatfield (3) | Coca-Cola Tigers | Don Allado (2) | Alaska Aces |
| Forward | Dennis Espino (2) | Sta. Lucia Realtors | Harvey Carey | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals |
| 2004–05 | Guard | Jimmy Alapag (2) | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals | Mark Caguioa | Barangay Ginebra Kings |
| Guard | Willie Miller (2) | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals | Olsen Racela (5) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Center | Dorian Peña | San Miguel Beermen | Mark Telan | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals |
| Forward | Eric Menk (2) | Barangay Ginebra Kings | Tony dela Cruz | Shell Turbo Chargers |
| Forward | Nic Belasco (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Rommel Adducul | Barangay Ginebra Kings |
| 2005–06 | Guard | Roger Yap | Purefoods Chunkee Giants | Mark Caguioa (2) | Barangay Ginebra Kings |
| Guard | James Yap^ | Purefoods Chunkee Giants | Mike Cortez | Alaska Aces |
| Center | Enrico Villanueva | Red Bull Barako | Dorian Peña (2) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Kerby Raymundo (2) | Purefoods Chunkee Giants | Danny Seigle (4) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Lordy Tugade | Red Bull Barako | Marc Pingris | Purefoods Chunkee Giants |
| 2006–07 | Guard | Gary David | Air21 Express | Wynne Arboleda | Air21 Express |
| Guard | Willie Miller (3) | Alaska Aces | Mark Cardona | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals |
| Center | Dorian Peña (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Yancy de Ocampo | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals |
| Forward | Jay Washington | Talk 'N Text Phone Pals | Danny Ildefonso (5) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Kelly Williams^ | Sta. Lucia Realtors | Arwind Santos | Air21 Express |
| 2007–08 | Guard | Jayjay Helterbrand | Barangay Ginebra Kings | Cyrus Baguio | Red Bull Barako |
| Guard | Mark Caguioa (3) | Barangay Ginebra Kings | Willie Miller (4) | Alaska Aces |
| Center | Asi Taulava (3) | Coca-Cola Tigers | Sonny Thoss | Alaska Aces |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (2) | Air21 Express | Kerby Raymundo (3) | Purefoods Tender Juicy Giants |
| Forward | Kelly Williams^ (2) | Sta. Lucia Realtors | Nelbert Omolon | Sta. Lucia Realtors |
| 2008–09 | Guard | Jayjay Helterbrand (2) | Barangay Ginebra Kings | Dondon Hontiveros | San Miguel Beermen |
| Guard | Mark Cardona (2) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters | Willie Miller (5) | Alaska Aces |
| Center | Asi Taulava (4) | Coca-Cola Tigers | Jay-R Reyes | Rain or Shine Elasto Painters |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (3) | Burger King Whoppers | Gabe Norwood^ | Rain or Shine Elasto Painters |
| Forward | Jay Washington (2) | San Miguel Beermen | Kelly Williams^ (3) | Sta. Lucia Realtors |
| 2009–10 | Guard | LA Tenorio^ | Alaska Aces | Roger Yap (2) | B-Meg Derby Ace Llamados |
| Guard | James Yap^ (2) | B-Meg Derby Ace Llamados | Mark Cardona (3) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters |
| Center | Sonny Thoss (2) | Alaska Aces | Asi Taulava (5) | Coca-Cola Tigers |
| Forward | Jay Washington (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Joe Devance | Alaska Aces |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (4) | San Miguel Beermen | Kelly Williams^ (4) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters |
| 2010–11 | Guard | Jimmy Alapag (3) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters | Jayson Castro^ | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters |
| Guard | Mark Caguioa (4) | Barangay Ginebra Kings | James Yap^ (3) | B-Meg Llamados |
| Center | Sonny Thoss (3) | Alaska Aces | Ali Peek (2) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters |
| Forward | Kelly Williams^ (5) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters | Joe Devance (2) | B-Meg Llamados |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (5) | Petron Blaze Boosters | Jay Washington (4) | Petron Blaze Boosters |
| 2011–12 | Guard | Mark Caguioa (5) | Barangay Ginebra Kings | Jayson Castro^ (2) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters |
| Guard | Gary David (2) | Powerade Tigers | Paul Lee^ | Rain or Shine Elasto Painters |
| Center | Ranidel de Ocampo | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters | Sonny Thoss (4) | Alaska Aces |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (6) | Petron Blaze Boosters | Jeff Chan^ | Rain or Shine Elasto Painters |
| Forward | James Yap^ (4) | B-Meg Llamados | Kelly Williams^ (6) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters |
| 2012–13 | Guard | Jayson Castro^ (3) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters | Alex Cabagnot^ | Petron Blaze Boosters |
| Guard | LA Tenorio^ (2) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | Cyrus Baguio (2) | Alaska Aces |
| Center | Ranidel de Ocampo (2) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters | June Mar Fajardo^ | Petron Blaze Boosters |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (7) | Petron Blaze Boosters | Marc Pingris (2) | San Mig Coffee Mixers |
| Forward | Calvin Abueva^ | Alaska Aces | Sonny Thoss (5) | Alaska Aces |
| 2013–14 | Guard | Jayson Castro^ (4) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters | Paul Lee^ (2) | Rain or Shine Elasto Painters |
| Guard | Mark Barroca^ | San Mig Super Coffee Mixers | Peter June Simon | San Mig Super Coffee Mixers |
| Center | June Mar Fajardo^ (2) | San Miguel Beermen | Greg Slaughter | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Forward | Ranidel de Ocampo (3) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters | Marc Pingris (3) | San Mig Super Coffee Mixers |
| Forward | Asi Taulava (6) | Air21 Express | Sonny Thoss (6) | Alaska Aces |
| 2014–15 | Guard | Jayson Castro^ (5) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters | Terrence Romeo^ | GlobalPort Batang Pier |
| Guard | Paul Lee^ (3) | Rain or Shine Elasto Painters | Stanley Pringle^ | GlobalPort Batang Pier |
| Center | Greg Slaughter (2) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | Asi Taulava (7) | NLEX Road Warriors |
| Forward | June Mar Fajardo^ (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Ranidel de Ocampo (4) | Talk 'N Text Tropang Texters |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (8) | San Miguel Beermen | Calvin Abueva^ (2) | Alaska Aces |
| 2015–16 | Guard | Jayson Castro^ (6) | TNT KaTropa | Alex Cabagnot^ (2) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Guard | Terrence Romeo^ (2) | GlobalPort Batang Pier | LA Tenorio^ (3) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Center | June Mar Fajardo^ (4) | San Miguel Beermen | Asi Taulava (8) | NLEX Road Warriors |
| Forward | Calvin Abueva^ (3) | Alaska Aces | Japeth Aguilar^ | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (9) | San Miguel Beermen | Sean Anthony^ | NLEX Road Warriors |
| 2016–17 | Guard | Alex Cabagnot^ (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Jayson Castro^ (7) | TNT KaTropa |
| Guard | Chris Ross^ | San Miguel Beermen | LA Tenorio^ (4) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Center | June Mar Fajardo^ (5) | San Miguel Beermen | Kelly Williams^ (7) | TNT KaTropa |
| Forward | Japeth Aguilar^ (2) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | Joe Devance (3) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (10) | San Miguel Beermen | Cliff Hodge^ | Meralco Bolts |
| 2017–18 | Guard | Stanley Pringle^ (2) | NorthPort Batang Pier | Scottie Thompson^ | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Guard | Paul Lee^ (4) | Magnolia Hotshots | Mark Barroca^ (2) | Magnolia Hotshots |
| Center | June Mar Fajardo^ (6) | San Miguel Beermen | Poy Erram^ | Blackwater Elite |
| Forward | Japeth Aguilar^ (3) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | Arwind Santos (11) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Forward | Marcio Lassiter^ | San Miguel Beermen | Matthew Wright | Phoenix Fuel Masters |
| 2019 | Guard | Jayson Castro^ (8) | TNT KaTropa | Roger Pogoy^ | TNT KaTropa |
| Guard | CJ Perez^ | Columbian Dyip | Stanley Pringle^ (3) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Center | June Mar Fajardo^ (7) | San Miguel Beermen | Japeth Aguilar^ (4) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Forward | Christian Standhardinger^ | NorthPort Batang Pier | Troy Rosario^ | TNT KaTropa |
| Forward | Sean Anthony^ (2) | NorthPort Batang Pier | Ian Sangalang^ | Magnolia Hotshots |
| 2020[a] | Guard | Stanley Pringle^ (4) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | No second team awarded this season. |
| Guard | Matthew Wright (2) | Phoenix Super LPG Fuel Masters |
| Center | Japeth Aguilar^ (5) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Forward | Poy Erram^ (2) | TNT Tropang Giga |
| Forward | Calvin Abueva^ (4) | Phoenix Super LPG Fuel Masters |
| 2021 | Guard | Mikey Williams^ | TNT Tropang Giga | Robert Bolick^ | NorthPort Batang Pier | |
| Guard | Scottie Thompson^ (2) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | CJ Perez^ (2) | San Miguel Beermen |
| Center | June Mar Fajardo^ (8) | San Miguel Beermen | Ian Sangalang^ (2) | Magnolia Hotshots |
| Forward | Calvin Abueva^ (5) | Magnolia Hotshots | Christian Standhardinger^ (2) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel |
| Forward | Arwind Santos (12) | NorthPort Batang Pier | Matthew Wright (3) | Phoenix Super LPG Fuel Masters |
| 2022–23 | Guard | CJ Perez^ (3) | San Miguel Beermen | Robert Bolick^ (2) | NorthPort Batang Pier | [1] |
| Guard | Scottie Thompson^ (3) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | Mikey Williams^ (2) | TNT Tropang Giga |
| Center/forward[b] | June Mar Fajardo^ (9) | San Miguel Beermen | Calvin Oftana^ | TNT Tropang Giga |
| Forward | Christian Standhardinger^ (3) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | Arvin Tolentino^ | NorthPort Batang Pier |
| Forward | Jamie Malonzo^ | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | Calvin Abueva^ (6) | Magnolia Hotshots |
| 2023–24 | Guard | CJ Perez^ (4) | San Miguel Beermen | Stephen Holt^ | Terrafirma Dyip | [2] |
| Guard | Chris Newsome^ | Meralco Bolts | Juami Tiongson^ | Terrafirma Dyip |
| Center/forward[c] | June Mar Fajardo^ (10) | San Miguel Beermen | Calvin Oftana^ (2) | TNT Tropang Giga |
| Forward | Christian Standhardinger^ (4) | Barangay Ginebra San Miguel | Cliff Hodge^ (2) | Meralco Bolts |
| Forward | Arvin Tolentino^ (2) | NorthPort Batang Pier | Jason Perkins^ | Phoenix Fuel Masters |
