List of Major League Baseball career fielding errors as an outfielder leaders

From Wikipedia the free encyclopedia

Tom Brown, the all-time leader in fielding errors as an outfielder

In baseball statistics, an error is an act, in the judgment of the official scorer, of a fielder misplaying a ball in a manner that allows a batter or baserunner to advance one or more bases or allows an at bat to continue after the batter should have been put out. An outfielder (OF) is a person playing in one of the three defensive positions in baseball farthest from the batter, who are identified as the left fielder (LF), the center fielder (CF), and the right fielder (RF). An outfielder's duty is to try to catch long fly balls before they hit the ground, or to quickly catch or retrieve and return to the infield any other balls entering the outfield. Outfielders normally play behind the six other members of the defense who play in or near the infield; unlike catchers and most infielders (excepting first basemen), who are virtually exclusively right-handed, outfielders can be either right- or left-handed. In the scoring system used to record defensive plays, the outfielders are assigned the numbers 7 (left field), 8 (center field) and 9 (right field).

The list of career leaders is dominated by players from the 19th century when fielding equipment was very rudimentary; baseball gloves only began to steadily gain acceptance in the 1880s, and were not uniformly worn until the mid-1890s, resulting in a much lower frequency of defensive miscues. The top 13 players in career errors began playing in the 19th century, most of them playing their entire careers before 1900; none of the 13 were active after 1905, and none of the top 29 were active after 1929. Most of the top 78 played entirely in the 19th century, with only four making their major league debut after 1920; only one was active after 1945. The top 42 single-season totals were all recorded before 1896, the top 100 were recorded before 1904, and the top 459 were recorded before 1937. To a large extent, the leaders reflect longevity rather than lower skill. Roberto Clemente, who became the first National League (NL) outfielder in over 40 years to commit 140 errors, won twelve Gold Glove Awards for defensive excellence.

Because game accounts and box scores often did not distinguish between the outfield positions, there has been some difficulty in determining precise defensive statistics prior to 1901; because of this, and because of the similarity in their roles, defensive statistics for the three positions are frequently combined. Tom Brown, who retired in 1898 after setting major league records for career games and assists as an outfielder, is the all-time leader in career errors committed by an outfielder with 492, more than twice as many as any outfielder who began playing after 1910; he is the only outfielder to be charged with more than 400 career errors. Dummy Hoy (394), Paul Hines (385), Jesse Burkett (383), George Gore (368), Jimmy Ryan (366), George Van Haltren (358), and Ned Hanlon (350) are the only other outfielders to commit more than 300 career errors. Justin Upton, who had 89 errors through the 2022 season to place him tied for 222nd all-time, is the leader among active players.

Key[edit]

Rank Rank amongst leaders in career errors committed. A blank field indicates a tie.
Player Name of player
Main pos. Primary outfield position played during career (LF, CF or RF)
E as OF Total career errors committed as an outfielder
* Denotes elected to National Baseball Hall of Fame

List[edit]

George Gore holds the National League record of 346 errors as an outfielder.
Ty Cobb's 271 errors as an outfielder are the American League record; he also holds the major league record for games as an outfielder.
Rank Player Main
Pos.
E as OF
1 Tom Brown CF 492
2 Dummy Hoy CF 394
3 Paul Hines CF 385
4 Jesse Burkett * LF 383
5 George Gore CF 368
6 Jimmy Ryan CF 366
7 George Van Haltren CF 358
8 Ned Hanlon * CF 350
9 Jim O'Rourke * LF 297
10 Tom York LF 291
11 Billy Hamilton * CF 289
12 Abner Dalrymple LF 285
13 George Wood LF 276
14 Ty Cobb * CF 271
15 Pete Browning CF 269
16 Tommy McCarthy * RF 262
17 King Kelly * RF 259
Orator Shafer RF 259
19 Fred Clarke * LF 256
20 Charley Jones LF 253
21 Pete Hotaling CF 246
22 Blondie Purcell LF 241
23 Max Carey * CF 235
24 Harry Stovey LF 230
25 Walt Wilmot LF 228
26 Tris Speaker * CF 222
27 Hugh Duffy * CF 220
28 Clyde Milan CF 216
29 Kip Selbach LF 214
30 Goose Goslin * LF 209
31 Emmett Seery LF 203
32 Patsy Donovan RF 201
33 Mike Smith LF 200
34 Jimmy Sheckard LF 197
35 Lou Brock * LF 196
Jack Manning RF 196
37 Cliff Carroll LF 194
38 Dick Johnston CF 193
39 Ed Swartwood RF 187
Mike Tiernan RF 187
41 Curt Welch CF 185
42 Sam Rice * RF 184
Burt Shotton CF 184
44 Zack Wheat * LF 183
45 Paul Radford RF 179
46 Joe Hornung LF 178
Jack Remsen CF 178
48 Cy Seymour CF 177
49 Mike Griffin CF 174
50 Sam Thompson * RF 172
Rank Player Main
Pos.
E as OF
51 Tip O'Neill LF 169
52 John Cassidy RF 168
53 Tilly Walker LF 167
Jimmy Wolf RF 167
55 Ed Delahanty * LF 166
56 Chief Roseman CF 162
57 Jim McTamany CF 161
58 Ned Cuthbert LF 160
59 Joe Sommer LF 157
60 Roy Johnson LF 156
61 Mike Dorgan RF 155
Babe Ruth * RF 155
63 Jimmy McAleer CF 154
Gee Walker LF 154
65 Eddie Burke LF 153
66 Harry Hooper * RF 151
67 Bill Crowley RF 150
Jimmy Slagle CF 150
Bobby Veach LF 150
70 Duff Cooley LF 146
Dave Eggler CF 146
Andy Leonard LF 146
Hugh Nicol RF 146
74 Ed Daily RF 145
Elmer Flick RF 145
Fred Treacey LF 145
77 Fielder Jones CF 144
Joe Kelley * LF 144
79 Sam Crawford * RF 143
Ducky Holmes LF 143
Mike Mansell LF 143
Willie Mays * CF 143
83 Steve Brodie CF 142
Patrick Gillespie LF 142
Reggie Jackson * RF 142
Dave Parker RF 142
87 Dick Harley LF 141
Rickey Henderson * LF 141
Bob Johnson LF 141
90 Roberto Clemente * RF 140
91 Ginger Beaumont CF 139
92 Willie Keeler * RF 138
93 George Browne RF 137
John Coleman RF 137
Tommy Dowd RF 137
Edd Roush * CF 137
Ken Williams LF 137
98 Billy Sunday RF 136
99 Mike Donlin CF 135
Chuck Klein * RF 135

Other Hall of Famers[edit]

Player Main
Pos.
E
Paul Waner * RF 132
Earl Averill * CF 126
Vladimir Guerrero * RF 125
Kiki Cuyler * RF 121
Hank Aaron * RF 117
Harry Heilmann * RF 117
Ross Youngs * RF 116
Ted Williams * LF 113
Richie Ashburn * CF 110
Joe DiMaggio * CF 105
Hack Wilson * CF 105
Billy Williams * LF 101
Mel Ott * RF 98
Earle Combs * CF 95
Dave Winfield * RF 95
Al Simmons * LF 94
Andre Dawson * RF 93
Minnie Miñoso * LF 92 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Billy Southworth * RF 92
Ken Griffey Jr. * CF 89
Casey Stengel * RF 87
Lloyd Waner * CF 87
Joe Medwick * LF 84
Willie Stargell * LF 84
Heinie Manush * LF 83
Mickey Mantle * CF 82
Enos Slaughter * RF 82
Carl Yastrzemski * LF 82
Chick Hafey * LF 80
Ralph Kiner * LF 80
John Montgomery Ward * CF 78
Al Kaline * RF 73
Frank Robinson * RF 68
Jim Rice * LF 66
Duke Snider * CF 66
Deacon White * RF 66
Stan Musial * LF 64
Larry Doby * CF 63 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Tony Gwynn * RF 62
Tony Oliva * RF 61
Tim Raines * LF 54
Turkey Stearnes * CF 54 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Kirby Puckett * CF 51
Larry Walker * RF 48
Harry Wright * CF 48
Harold Baines * RF 47
George Davis * CF 47
Cool Papa Bell * CF 42 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Oscar Charleston * CF 39 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Robin Yount * CF 32
Cap Anson * LF 31
Monte Irvin * LF 28 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Honus Wagner * RF 28
Roger Bresnahan * CF 26
Cristóbal Torriente * CF 25 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Freddie Lindstrom * CF 24
Willie McCovey * LF 23
Willard Brown * CF 20 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Mule Suttles * LF 20 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Hank Greenberg * LF 18
Craig Biggio * CF 15
Orlando Cepeda * LF 12
Martín Dihigo * CF 6 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Pete Hill * LF 6 (includes incomplete Negro league totals)
Paul Molitor * CF 3
Todd Helton * LF 0
Joe Mauer * RF 0

References[edit]