Carol City murders

Carol City Murders
Map of Miami-Dade County highlighting Carol City
Location	Carol City, Florida, United States
Date	October 1974–January 1978
Attack type	Robbery, rape, murder, mass shooting
Weapons	Handgun, knife
Deaths	12
Perpetrators	John Errol Ferguson Marvin Francois Beauford White
Motive	Unknown

The Carol City murders were a series of murders that took place predominantly in Carol City, Florida and in and around Miami-Dade County between October 1974 and January 1978. The murders were committed by American mass murderer and serial killer John Errol Ferguson (February 27, 1948 – August 5, 2013)^[1] who murdered at least eight people but is believed to have killed up to twelve. He was aided in six of the murders by two accomplices: Marvin Francois (January 18, 1946 – May 29, 1985)^[2] and Beauford James White^[3] (October 29, 1945 – August 28, 1987).^[2]

On July 27, 1977, Ferguson, Francois, and White entered a drug house in Carol City where they tied up a total of eight people and shot all of them in the head execution-style. Two of the eight survived. At the time, the incident was the largest case of mass murder in Miami-Dade County history. Months after the massacre, Ferguson murdered a teenage couple in Hialeah after raping the female victim. He is also suspected to be responsible for the May 1977 murders of an elderly couple and is suspected of killing a further two men in 1974.^[4]

Ferguson, Francois, and White were all eventually captured, sentenced to death, and executed by the state of Florida. Francois was executed in the electric chair on May 29, 1985, followed by White, who was also executed in the electric chair on August 28, 1987. Ferguson was executed over two decades later by lethal injection on August 5, 2013, following years of appeals over his sanity.^[5][6]

Ferguson, the fourth oldest of eight children, had been known to psychiatrists since he was 10. His father died when he was 13 and his mother had managed to take care of the children on her own. Ferguson dropped out of school after repeating 9th grade three times.^[7] Ferguson had his first police encounter when he was 13 after being caught driving someone else's car without their consent. He would continue to get in trouble with the police throughout his youth. In 1969, Ferguson tried to kill a police officer after a traffic stop. He disarmed officer Edward Hartman, ordered him on his knees, and told him to beg for his life. Hartman complied, but also slipped a revolver out of his boot. Ferguson fired four shots at Hartman but missed all of them. Hartman then shot Ferguson four times.^[7]

In 1975, a court-appointed psychiatrist diagnosed John Ferguson as "dangerous to himself and others ... homicidal ... a man who should not be released under any circumstances." Another psychiatrist said Ferguson's potential for recovery was minimal and that the probability of him returning to a life of crime was very high. He described Ferguson as "explosive ... a dangerous person who cannot cope with day to day living." Ferguson bragged to his friends that he had feigned insanity and misled the doctors. A woman who knew him later said, "He was into psychology. He told us he psyched them out. He'd say things like 'See that airplane flying in the room?'"^[7]

After repeatedly escaping from a hospital, Ferguson, who had previously been acquitted of six robberies and two assaults on the grounds of insanity, was sent to the more secure Florida State Hospital. In June 1976, doctors said Ferguson's treatment was complete and that further hospitalization was not necessary. Ferguson was sent to Miami to face charges of resisting arrest after a hospital escape. Although a psychiatrist warned that he was "unpredictable and a danger to himself and others", a judge ruled Ferguson competent and later accepted a guilty plea. He was sentenced to 18 months in prison and two years of probation, and released 225 days later.^[7]

Francois, whose parents were not married, had an impoverished upbringing. His father was a deadbeat heroin addict who brought other addicts into the home to take heroin in front of his son and beat Francois when he would not fight with the other children. Francois's mother was a sex worker who did not do much for her son. She married, but Francois's stepfather abused him. Although Francois did not finish school, he did obtain his GED.^[8]

White had a lengthy criminal record dating back to July 1963, and was on parole for assault with intent to commit rape at the time of the murders.^[9]

On October 30, 1974, James Ward, a 40-year-old mental hospital escapee, was murdered. His body was dumped in Collier County and he was killed by a shotgun blast. On November 1, the body of another man named Joseph Walters was found near railroad tracks in Miami by a freight train employee. Walters had also been killed by a shotgun blast but had additionally been shot repeatedly with a handgun. There were no leads in the Walters case until February 1977, when the mother of the man convicted of Ward's murder made contact with Linda Blue, the lead homicide detective who was investigating the case. Convicted killer Edward Eugene Oliver had been spotted leaving the area where Ward's body had been found and was ultimately convicted of murdering him. Oliver made contact with Blue and claimed he wanted to talk about both murders.^[10][11]

On February 11, 1977, Oliver told Blue that he and John Errol Ferguson had carried out the murders of both Walters and Ward and that Ferguson was the shooter. Oliver stated that he, Ferguson, Walters, and Ward had all been part of a gang that had robbed a Miami clothing store and a warehouse on Florida's west coast. Ward had then been tasked with selling the merchandise but had instead disappeared, apparently intending to keep the loot all for himself. In October 1974, Ferguson and Oliver tracked down Walters, who refused to talk. According to Oliver, Ferguson then killed him with a shotgun, before dumping his body near railroad tracks in Miami. The two men then found Ward on October 30, with Oliver claiming it was also Ferguson who shot and killed him. After the two dumped his body in Collier County, only Oliver was spotted leaving the area. He was arrested and charged with the murder of Ward. After the interview, Oliver was given a polygraph examination, which he passed. Additionally, clothing found in Walters' home linked him to the burglary at the Miami clothing store.^[10][12]

Ferguson was already in jail at the time of the revelation for an unrelated crime and was serving an eighteen-month sentence for resisting arrest. As he was due for parole in April, Blue wanted to hurry and charge Ferguson. He was brought to the Dade County Jail, however, the charges were never filed. After Blue sent the case to the state attorney's office, the assistant state attorney refused to file any charges, as according to him, Oliver's words were insufficient for prosecution, and he wanted more proof of Ferguson's involvement. Blue thought Oliver's testimony was sufficient grounds for charging Ferguson, however, Oliver also wanted immunity in exchange for his testimony, which the assistant state attorney would not offer. As no charges were filed, Ferguson was paroled in April 1977.^[10]

In May 1977, the bodies of 75-year-old Raymond Perry, and his wife, 82-year-old Katherine Perry, were found in their room at the Gold Dust Motel in Miami. The couple, who were from St. Petersburg, Florida, had been tied up, beaten, robbed, and shot to death execution-style. The gun used to kill them was a handgun.^[13]

On July 27, 1977, Ferguson, accompanied by Marvin Francois, Beauford White, and Adolphus Archie, drove to the home of 33-year-old Livingston Stocker, a Vietnam veteran and small-time marijuana dealer. Ferguson, who was posing as a Florida Power & Light Company worker, knocked on the door of Stocker's home, in Carol City, Florida. 24-year-old Margaret Wooden answered, and Ferguson gained access to the property. After checking several rooms, he drew a handgun, tied up Wooden, and then blindfolded her. He then opened the front door to let Francois and White inside, while Archie waited outside in the car as a getaway driver. All the men wore masks and were armed with guns. The men ransacked and searched the property for drugs and money.^[13][3][14]

Approximately two hours later, six of Wooden's friends, including Stocker, arrived at the house. The trio ambushed them, searched them, tied them up, and then blindfolded each of them. A short time later, another one of Stocker's friends, 24-year-old Michael Miller, entered the property and was also ambushed, bound, and searched. Miller and Wooden were placed in the bedroom and the other six were bound in the living room. After this, the mask Francois was wearing fell off and revealed his face. Ferguson then said they would have to kill everyone.^[13][3][14]

Francois shot all six people in the living room with a shotgun execution-style. He fatally shot Stocker, 35-year-old Henry Clayton, 26-year-old John Holmes, 37-year-old Gilbert Williams, and 35-year-old Charles Stinson. He also shot 45-year-old Johnnie Hall, who survived. Ferguson headed to the bedroom and shot both Wooden and Miller in the head with a handgun, also execution-style. Wooden had heard shots coming from the living room and witnessed a pillow come toward her head. She was then shot and witnessed Miller being fatally shot in the head. Although Wooden did not personally see the shooter, she did hear Ferguson run out of the room.^[13][3][14]

While the shootings occurred, White remained by the front door with a gun to prevent anyone from entering or escaping the property. The gunmen then left. Wooden and Hall survived by turning their heads as the shootings occurred. Wooden eventually managed to get to her feet, escape the property, and run to a neighbor's house, where she called the police. When the police arrived, they found the six dead bodies, all of whom had been shot in the back of the head, and had their hands tied behind their backs.^[13][3][14]

According to Archie, the killers drove to a motel room after the massacre and split the stolen money, which totaled around $800. In Archie's testimony, he claimed Francois bragged about the killings and compared them to the Saint Valentine's Day Massacre, while White was upset and looked like he had seen a ghost.^[3]

On September 1, 1977, police arrested Archie while questioning him at the Dade County Sheriff's Office. In the early hours of September 2, Francois was arrested at the Dade County Jail, where he was being held on unrelated shoplifting charges. White was arrested at the Ron Dini Motel later that day. Ferguson, however, remained at large.^[15]

On January 8, 1978, 17-year-old Brian Glenfeldt and 17-year-old Belinda Worley, a couple, left a Youth-for-Christ meeting in Hialeah. They were meant to meet up with friends at an ice cream parlor, however, they never showed up. Instead, the two had gone for ice cream at Farrell's Ice Cream Parlor, located at Hialeah's Westland Mall. They then left and parked at a field known as a popular lovers' lane. Ferguson then approached them, posing as a police officer, intending to rob the couple. He fatally shot Glenfeldt behind the wheel of his mother's car, before taking Worley into the nearby woods where he raped and murdered her.^[4][14]

At 2:00 a.m. the families of Glenfeldt and Worley filed missing person reports for both of them. The following morning, Worley's body was discovered under an Australian pine tree in a wooded area. A quarter-mile away, Glenfeldt's body was also located. He had a bullet in his head and was still slumped over behind the wheel of his mother's car. It was determined the shot to the head had killed him, but he had also been shot in the chest and arm. All of Worley's clothes, apart from her jeans, were next to her body. She had been killed by a shot to the back of the head. An autopsy later revealed that she had been raped. Jewelry had been stolen from her body and cash in Glenfeldt's wallet had also been taken.^[4][14]

On April 5, 1978, Ferguson was finally captured after the FBI received a tip that he was at an apartment. FBI agents arrived to take him into custody, but Ferguson refused to open the door. Afterward, the agents kicked it down and cornered Ferguson in the living room, where he was wielding a handgun and pointing it at the ceiling. He told them not to shoot him. Ferguson was then arrested and taken into custody.^[13][14]

Francois was the first of the three killers to be convicted. On April 24, 1978, he was sentenced to death for his role in the Carol City massacre.^[16] The jury had recommended a death sentence.^[17][18]

White's trial proved more controversial. His defense argued that he did not actually kill anyone and instead acted as a lookout by standing watch at the door of the property as the killings occurred. As such, the jury unanimously recommended that he be sentenced to life in prison. On April 27, 1978, the judge overrode the recommendation and sentenced White to death, partly citing his criminal record.^[19][20] In 1984, his death sentence was overturned by a Dade Circuit judge, who resentenced him to life in prison. On April 25, 1985, the Supreme Court of Florida reversed the decision and reinstated White's death sentence.^[3][21]

Ferguson was tried last.^[22] On May 25, 1978, he was sentenced to death for his role in the Carol City massacre.^[23] On October 7, 1978, he received a further two death sentences for the Hialeah murders.^[24] In 1982, the Supreme Court of Florida threw out the death sentence, saying that the judge failed to consider evidence of Ferguson's mental illness. However, a year later, he was resentenced to death.^[4] He was never charged in the 1974 murders of Walters and Ward, or the 1977 motel murders of Raymond and Katherine Perry. However, the handgun used in the Carol City massacre and the Hialeah murders was found to be the same handgun that had been used in the motel murders and the shooting of Walters.^[13]

Archie pleaded guilty to six counts of second degree murder and was sentenced to 20 years in prison for his role as the getaway driver in the Carol City massacre. He was the state's key witness in the trials of Ferguson, Francois, and White.^[3] Archie has since been released from prison.

On May 29, 1985, Francois was executed in the electric chair. He was executed shortly after 7:00 a.m. and spent his final hours with his mother, girlfriend, and twin teenage children.^[25] His last meal consisted of shrimp, lobster tail, barbecued spare ribs, chicken breast, watermelon, strawberries, sliced tomatoes, and french fries. He refused the services of a clergyman.^[26]

Reading from a written last statement, Francois said

The Miami institutionalized white racist judiciary and law enforcement systems have made me, the once heroin addict, the scapegoat, with fabricated assertions, dishonest policemen, unethical judges, unethical state attorneys, drug pushers, and drug users for their political and personal ambitions and their inability and unwillingness to control the drug sphere of Miami's communities as America made Grenada the scapegoat for their inability or unwillingness to control the blowing up of the American Embassy in Lebanon where many soldiers were killed. That is the plight of the black race at the hands of the white race, be it one black like me or many blacks as in South Africa. The state of Florida honors the drug merchants of the black community with my death as the white race honors King and Tutu with Nobel Peace Prizes for the death of the minds of the black race. I do not extend sympathy to me, for I am as a grain of sand on the beach of the black race. The black race has lost its pride and dignity and is slowly dying from within and without, and blind with seeing eyes. My death ends my tears and the fortune of watching my race slowly die. I am a black American, Ashanti Ankobia. I join my ancestors.

After finishing his written statement, Francois said "If there is such a thing as an Antichrist, it ain't one man but the whole white race."^[27][28][29]

On August 28, 1987, White was executed in the electric chair.^[30] He was pronounced dead at 7:11 a.m. at Florida State Prison. When asked if he had any last words, White said "No, sir."^[31] He was originally scheduled to be executed in February 1984 but had been granted a reprieve.^[32][33]

On August 5, 2013, Ferguson was executed by lethal injection after spending thirty-five years on death row. He was pronounced dead at 6:17 p.m. and his last meal was a standard prison meal consisting of a meat patty with white bread, steamed tomatoes, potato salad, diced carrots, and iced tea. His execution was repeatedly delayed following years of appeals over his sanity, with his attorneys arguing that he was severely mentally ill and had succumbed to delusions and hallucinations, including a belief that he would rise up after his execution to fight alongside Jesus and save America from a communist plot. His final statement was "I just want everyone to know that I am the Prince of God and I will rise again."^[6]

• Capital punishment in Florida
• List of people executed in Florida
• List of people executed in the United States in 2013
• List of serial killers in the United States