Date of ceremony Recipient March 24, 1991 Sofia Coppola Sofia Coppola in The Godfather Part III as Mary Corleone Ingrid Chavez in Graffiti Bridge as Aura Leo Damian in Ghosts Can't Do It as Fausto Carre Otis in Wild Orchid as Emily Reed Donald Trump (as himself) in Ghosts Can't Do It March 29, 1992 Vanilla Ice Vanilla Ice in Cool as Ice as Johnny Van Owen[2] Brian Bosworth in Stone Cold as Joe Huff / John Stone Milla Jovovich in Return to the Blue Lagoon as Lilli Hargrave Brian Krause in Return to the Blue Lagoon as Richard Lestrange, Jr. Kristin Minter in Cool as Ice as Kathy Winslow March 28, 1993 Pauly Shore Pauly Shore in Encino Man as Stoney[3] Georges Corraface in Christopher Columbus: The Discovery as Christopher Columbus Kevin Costner 's crew cut in The Bodyguard Whitney Houston in The Bodyguard as Rachel Marron Sharon Stone 's tribute to Theodore Cleaver in Basic Instinct March 20, 1994 Janet Jackson Janet Jackson in Poetic Justice as Justice Roberto Benigni in Son of the Pink Panther as Gendarme Jacques Gambrelli Mason Gamble in Dennis the Menace as Dennis Mitchell Norman D. Golden II in Cop and a Half as Devon Butler Austin O'Brien in Last Action Hero as Danny Madigan March 26, 1995 Anna Nicole Smith Anna Nicole Smith in Naked Gun 33+ 1 ⁄3 : The Final Insult as Tanya Peters Jim Carrey in Ace Ventura: Pet Detective (as Ace Ventura ), Dumb and Dumber (as Lloyd Christmas) and The Mask (as Stanley Ipkiss/The Mask) Chris Elliott in Cabin Boy as Nathaniel Mayweather Chris Isaak in Little Buddha as Dean Conrad Shaquille O'Neal in Blue Chips as Deon March 24, 1996 Elizabeth Berkley Elizabeth Berkley in Showgirls as Nomi Malone[1] Amy the talking gorilla in Congo David Caruso in Jade and Kiss of Death as David Corelli and Jimmy Kilmartin (respectively) Cindy Crawford in Fair Game as Kate McQuean Julia Sweeney in It's Pat: The Movie (as Pat Riley) and Stuart Saves His Family March 23, 1997 Pamela Anderson Pamela Anderson in Barb Wire as Barb Wire[4] Beavis and Butt-head in Beavis and Butt-head Do America Ellen DeGeneres in Mr. Wrong as Martha Alston Friends cast members turned movie star wannabes (Jennifer Aniston in She's the One , Lisa Kudrow in Mother , Matt LeBlanc in Ed , David Schwimmer in The Pallbearer ) The new "serious" Sharon Stone in Diabolique and Last Dance as Nicole Horner and Cindy Liggett (respectively) March 22, 1998 Dennis Rodman Dennis Rodman in Double Team as Yaz The animatronic anaconda in Anaconda Tori Spelling in The House of Yes and Scream 2 as Lesly and herself (respectively) Howard Stern in Private Parts as himself Chris Tucker in The Fifth Element and Money Talks as Ruby Rhod and Franklin Hatchett March 20, 1999 Jerry Springer Joe Eszterhas in An Alan Smithee Film: Burn Hollywood Burn as himself (tie)[5] Jerry Springer in Ringmaster as Jerry Farrelly (tie) Barney the Friendly Dinosaur in Barney's Great Adventure: The Movie Carrot Top in Chairman of the Board as Edison The Spice Girls in Spice World as themselves