# | Wrestlers | Reign | Date | Days held | Location | Event | Notes | Ref |
1 | Joe O. | 1 | November 18, 1991 | 84 | Swansea, Massachusetts | Power League Wrestling | Joe O. defeated The Shadow Warrior in a tournament final to become the first PLW Heavyweight Champion. | |
2 | Storm Kelly | 1 | February 10, 1992 | N/A | Swansea, Massachusetts | Power League Wrestling | Kelly won the title after secretly switching places with masked wrestler The Shadow Warrior during a Best 2-of-3 Falls match. Kelly unmasked immediately afterwards and claimed to have wrestled the entire match. | |
— | Vacated | — | February 1992 | — | — | Power League Wrestling | Kelly was stripped of the title by PLW President Pinky Johnson due to the controversy surrounding the title change. This aired February 1992. | |
3 | Ryan Amaral | 1 | March 9, 1992 | N/A | Swansea, Massachusetts | PowerFest (1992) | Amaral defeated "Brutal" Bob Evans in a tournament final to win the vacant title. | |
— | Vacated | — | April 1992 | — | — | Power League Wrestling | Amaral was stripped of the title by PLW President Pinky Johnson due to the champion using excessive violence against Bob Evans at PowerFest 1992. This aired April 1992. | |
4 | The Shadow Warrior | 1 | May 1992 | N/A | Swansea, Massachusetts | Trials and Tribulations Tournament | The Shadow Warrior defeated Joe O. in a tournament final to win the vacant title. | |
5 | Scott Z. | 1 | September 27, 1992 | 70 | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | Power League Wrestling | | |
6 | Hurricane Harvey | 1 | December 6, 1992 | 10 | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | Power League Wrestling | | |
— | Vacated | — | December 1992 | — | N/A | Power League Wrestling | Hurricane Harvey surrendered the title after being injured in a car accident. | |
7 | Scott Z. | 2 | December 16, 1992 | 70 | Swansea, Massachusetts | Power League Wrestling | Scott Z. defeated The Defenseman in a singles match to win the vacant title; The Defenseman had previously won a 12-man battle royal to face Scott Z. for the title. | |
8 | Joe O. | 2 | February 24, 1993 | 35 | Swansea, Massachusetts | Power League Wrestling | | |
9 | Scott Z. | 3 | March 31, 1993 | 46 | Swansea, Massachusetts | Power League Wrestling | | |
10 | Bob Evans | 1 | May 16, 1993 | N/A | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | Power League Wrestling | | [1] |
— | Vacated | — | June 1993 | — | N/A | Power League Wrestling | Evans surrendered the title upon leaving the promotion. | [1] |
11 | Maniacal Mark | 1 | June 30, 1993 | 165 | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | Power League Wrestling | Maniacal Mark defeated Sub-Zero in a tournament final to win the vacant title. Sub-Zero was a last minute substitute for Scott Z. who had injured his knee prior to the match; according to the pre-match stipulations, Scott Z. would have been awarded the title had Sub-Zero won the match. | |
12 | Amazin' Jay | 1 | December 12, 1993 | 231 | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | Power League Wrestling | | |
13 | Scott Z. | 4 | July 31, 1994 | 105 | Cranston, Rhode Island | Power League Wrestling | | |
14 | The Punisher | 1 | November 13, 1994 | 118 | Providence, Rhode Island | Power League Wrestling | | |
15 | Sub-Zero | 1 | March 11, 1995 | 274 | Cranston, Rhode Island | Power League Wrestling | | |
16 | Amazin' Jay | 2 | December 10, 1995 | 201 | Providence, Rhode Island | Power-House Brawl (1995) | | |
17 | T.J. Richter | 1 | June 28, 1996 | 205 | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | PowerFest (1996) | Richter was disguised as Knightmare, Jay's scheduled opponent, and revealed his indenity after the match. | |
18 | Shane Simons | 1 | January 19, 1997 | 119 | Warren, Rhode Island | The War In Warren | | |
— | Vacated | — | May 18, 1997 | — | Newport, Rhode Island | Live event | Simons surrenders the championship due to injury. | |
19 | Jason the Slasher | 1 | May 18, 1997 | 34 | Newport, Rhode Island | Live event | Jason the Slasher defeated Amazin' Jay, Bob Evans, Maniacal Mark, Paul Lauzon, and T.J. Richter in a Pier 6 Brawl match to win the vacant title. | |
20 | Derek Molhan | 1 | June 21, 1997 | 357 | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | PowerFest (1997) | This was a steel cage match. | |
21 | The Universal Soldier | 1 | June 13, 1998 | 286 | Manville, Rhode Island | Slammin' for Zachary | | |
22 | Gino Martino | 1 | March 26, 1999 | 0 | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | Live event | | [2] |
— | Vacated | — | March 26, 1999 | — | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | Live event | Immediately after winning the title from The Universal Soldier, Martino turned the title over to Scott Knight; PLW officials nullified this decision, and vacated the title. | |
23 | Paul Lauzon | 1 | May 16, 1999 | N/A | Warwick, Rhode Island | PowerFest (1999) | Paul Lauzon defeated The Universal Soldier in a singles match to win the vacant title. | |
— | Vacated | — | August 1999 | — | N/A | N/A | Lauzon surrendered the title upon retiring. | |
24 | Don Juan de Santo | 1 | August 29, 1999 | 384 | Manville, Rhode Island | Live event | Don Juan de Santo defeated T.J. Richter in a tournament final to win the vacant title. | |
25 | Dr. Heresy | 1 | September 16, 2000 | 470 | Providence, Rhode Island | Jalen Noon-Coulbourn Benefit Show | This was a Triple Threat match also involving Chris Venom. | [3] |
26 | Johnny Angel | 1 | December 30, 2001 | 140 | West Warwick, Rhode Island | Power-House Brawl (2001) | | [4][5][6][7] |
— | Vacated | — | May 19, 2002 | — | Central Falls, Rhode Island | PowerFest (2002) | The championship is vacated by PLW Commissioner Derek Molhan when Johnny Angel is unable to appear for a scheduled title defense at PowerFest 2002. | |
27 | Dr. Heresy | 2 | May 19, 2002 | 714 | Central Falls, Rhode Island | PowerFest (2002) | Dr. Heresy defeated Johnny Curtis, Derik Destiny, Kid Krazy, Manical Mark, Kenn Phoenix, Shane Simons, and Don Vega in a Pier 8 Brawl match to win the vacant title. | |
28 | Derik Destiny | 1 | May 2, 2004 | 510 | Brockton, Massachusetts | PowerFest (2004) | | |
29 | Jason the Slasher | 2 | September 24, 2005 | 603 | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | Live event | [8] | |
30 | Chris Blackheart | 1 | May 20, 2007 | 350 | West Warwick, Rhode Island | PowerFest (2007) | | [9] |
31 | Don Vega | 1 | May 4, 2008 | 1,239 | West Warwick, Rhode Island | PowerFest (2008) | | |
— | Vacated | — | September 25, 2011 | — | Plainville, Massachusetts | Great Outdoors Tour (2011) | The championship is vacated by PLW President Tom James due to Vega being unable to defend the title due to injury. | |
32 | Scott Levesque | 1 | September 25, 2011 | 322 | Plainville, Massachusetts | Great Outdoors Tour (2011) | Levesque defeated "English Lion" Eddie Ryan in a singles match to win the vacant title. | [10] |
33 | J. T. Dunn | 1 | August 12, 2012 | 280 | Cumberland, Rhode Island | Cumberlandfest (2012) | | |
34 | Scott Levesque | 2 | May 19, 2013 | 133 | Pawtucket, Rhode Island | PowerFest (2013) | | |
35 | Matt Storm | 1 | September 29, 2013 | 573 | Plainville, Massachusetts | Great Outdoors Tour (2013) | | |
36 | Scott Levesque | 3 | April 25, 2015 | 251 | Glocester, Rhode Island | PowerFest (2015) | | |