| Jaar | Winnaar | Score | Stadion/Gastclub | MVP |
| 1933 | American | 4 - 2 | Comiskey Park, Chicago White Sox | |
| 1934 | American | 9 - 7 | Polo Grounds, New York Giants | |
| 1935 | American | 4 - 1 | Municipal Stadium, Cleveland Indians | |
| 1936 | National | 4 - 3 | Braves Field, Boston Braves | |
| 1937 | American | 8 - 3 | Griffith Stadium, Washington Senators | |
| 1938 | National | 4 - 1 | Crosley Field, Cincinnati Reds | |
| 1939 | American | 3 - 1 | Yankee Stadium, New York Yankees | |
| 1940 | National | 4 - 0 | Sportsman's Park, St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 1941 | American | 7 - 5 | Briggs Stadium, Detroit Tigers | |
| 1942 | American | 3 - 1 | Polo Grounds, New York Giants | |
| 1943 | American | 5 - 3 | Shibe Park, Philadelphia Athletics | |
| 1944 | National | 7 - 1 | Forbes Park, Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 1945 | Niet gehouden |
| 1946 | American | 12 - 0 | Fenway Park, Boston Red Sox | |
| 1947 | American | 2 - 1 | Wrigley Field, Chicago Cubs | |
| 1948 | American | 5 - 2 | Sportsman's Park, St. Louis Browns | |
| 1949 | American | 11 - 7 | Ebbets Field, Brooklyn Dodgers | |
| 1950 | National | 4 - 3
(14 innings) | Comiskey Park, Chicago White Sox | |
| 1951 | National | 8 - 3 | Briggs Stadium, Detroit Tigers | |
| 1952 | National | 3 - 2
(5 innings, regen) | Shibe Park, Philadelphia Phillies | |
| 1953 | National | 5 - 1 | Crosley Field, Cincinnati Reds | |
| 1954 | American | 11 - 9 | Municipal Stadium, Cleveland Indians | |
| 1955 | National | 6 - 5
(12 innings) | County Stadium, Milwaukee Braves | |
| 1956 | National | 7 - 3 | Griffith Stadium, Washington Senators | |
| 1957 | American | 6 - 5 | Sportsman's Park, St. Louis Cardinals | |
| 1958 | American | 4 - 3 | Memorial Stadium, Baltimore Orioles | |
| 1959-a | National | 5 - 4 | Forbes Field, Pittsburgh Pirates | |
| 1959-b | American | 5 - 3 | Memorial Coliseum, Los Angeles Dodgers | |
| 1960-a | National | 5 - 3 | Municipal Stadium, Kansas City Athletics | |
| 1960-b | National | 6 - 0 | Yankee Stadium, New York Yankees | |
| 1961-a | National | 5 - 4
(10 innings) | Candlestick Park, San Francisco Giants | |
| 1961-b | Gelijk | 1 - 1
(9 innings, regen) | Fenway Park, Boston Red Sox | |
| 1962-a | National | 3 - 1 | D.C. Stadium, Washington Senators | Maury Wills, Los Angeles Dodgers (NL) |
| 1962-b | American | 9 - 4 | Wrigley Field, Chicago Cubs | Leon Wagner, Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim (AL) |
| 1963 | National | 5 - 3 | Municipal Stadium, Cleveland Indians | Willie Mays, San Francisco Giants (NL) |
| 1964 | National | 7 - 4 | Shea Stadium, New York Mets | Johnny Callison, Philadelphia Phillies (NL) |
| 1965 | National | 6 - 5 | Metropolitan Stadium, Minnesota Twins | Juan Marichal, San Francisco Giants (NL) |
| 1966 | National | 2 - 1
(10 innings) | Busch Memorial Stadium, St. Louis Cardinals | Brooks Robinson, Baltimore Orioles (AL) |
| 1967 | National | 2 - 1
(15 innings) | Anaheim Stadium, Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | Tony Perez, Cincinnati Reds (NL) |
| 1968 | National | 1 - 0 | Astrodome, Houston Astros | Willie Mays, San Francisco Giants (NL) |
| 1969 | National | 9 - 3 | Robert F. Kennedy Memorial Stadium, Washington Senators | Willie McCovery, San Francisco Giants (NL) |
| 1970 | National | 5 - 4
(12 innings) | Riverfront Stadium, Cincinnati Reds | Carl Yastrzemski, Boston Red Sox (AL) |
| 1971 | American | 6 - 4 | Tiger Stadium, Detroit Tigers | Frank Robinson, Baltimore Orioles (AL) |
| 1972 | National | 4 - 3
(10 innings) | Atlanta Fulton County Stadium, Atlanta Braves | Joe Morgan, Cincinnati Reds (NL) |
| 1973 | National | 7 - 1 | Royals Stadium, Kansas City Royals | Bobby Bonds, San Francisco Giants (NL) |
| 1974 | National | 7 - 2 | Three Rivers Stadium, Pittsburgh Pirates | Steve Garvey, Los Angeles Dodgers (NL) |
| 1975 | National | 6 - 3 | County Stadium, Milwaukee Brewers | Jon Matlack, New York Mets (NL)
Bill Madlock, Chicago Cubs (NL) |
| 1976 | National | 7 - 1 | Veterans Stadium, Philadelphia Phillies | George Foster, Cincinnati Reds (NL) |
| 1977 | National | 7 - 5 | Yankee Stadium, New York Yankees | Don Sutton, Los Angeles Dodgers (NL) |
| 1978 | National | 7 - 3 | San Diego Stadium, San Diego Padres | Steve Garvey, Los Angeles Dodgers (NL) |
| 1979 | National | 7 - 6 | Kingdome, Seattle Mariners | Dave Parker, Pittsburgh Pirates (NL) |
| 1980 | National | 4 - 2 | Dodger Stadium, Los Angeles Dodgers | Ken Griffey Sr., Cincinnati Reds (NL) |
| 1981 | National | 5 - 4 | Cleveland Stadium, Cleveland Indians | Gary Carters, Montreal Expos (NL) |
| 1982 | National | 4 - 1 | Olympic Stadium, Montreal Expos | Dave Concepcion, Cincinnati Reds (NL) |
| 1983 | American | 13 - 3 | Comiskey Park, Chicago White Sox | Fred Lynn, Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim (AL) |
| 1984 | National | 3 - 1 | Candlestick Park, San Francisco Giants | Gary Carter, Montreal Expos (NL) |
| 1985 | National | 6 - 1 | Hubert H. Humphrey Metrodome, Minnesota Twins | LaMarr Hoyt, San Diego Padres (NL) |
| 1986 | American | 3 - 2 | Astrodome, Houston Astros | Roger Clemens, Boston Red Sox (AL) |
| 1987 | National | 2 - 0
(13 innings) | Oakland-Alameda County Coliseum, Oakland Athletics | Tim Raines, Montreal (NL) |
| 1988 | American | 2 - 1 | Riverfront Stadium, Cincinnati Reds | Terry Steinbach, Oakland Athletics (AL) |
| 1989 | American | 5 - 3 | Anaheim Stadium, California Angels | Bo Jackson, Kansas City Royals (AL) |
| 1990 | American | 2 - 0 | Wrigley Field, Chicago Cubs | Julio Franco, Texas Rangers (AL) |
| 1991 | American | 4 - 2 | SkyDome, Toronto Blue Jays | Cal Ripken Jr., Baltimore Orioles (AL) |
| 1992 | American | 13 - 6 | Jack Murphy Stadium, San Diego Padres | Ken Griffey Jr., Seattle Mariners (AL) |
| 1993 | American | 9 - 3 | Oriole Park at Camden Yards, Baltimore Orioles | Kirby Puckett, Minnesota Twins (AL) |
| 1994 | National | 8 - 7
(10 innings) | Three Rivers Stadium, Pittsburgh Pirates | Fred McGriff, Atlanta Braves (NL) |
| 1995 | National | 3 - 2 | Ameriquest Field in Arlington, Texas Rangers | Jeff Conine, Florida Marlins (NL) |
| 1996 | National | 6 - 0 | Veterans Stadium, Philadelphia Phillies | Mike Piazza, Los Angeles Dodgers (NL) |
| 1997 | American | 3 - 1 | Jacobs Field, Cleveland Indians | Sandy Alomar, Cleveland Indians (AL) |
| 1998 | American | 13 - 8 | Coors Field, Colorado Rockies | Roberto Alomar, Baltimore Orioles (AL) |
| 1999 | American | 4 - 1 | Fenway Park, Boston Red Sox | Pedro Martínez, Boston Red Sox (AL) |
| 2000 | American | 6 - 3 | Turner Field, Atlanta Braves | Derek Jeter, New York Yankees (AL) |
| 2001 | American | 4 - 1 | Safeco Field, Seattle Mariners | Cal Ripken Jr., Baltimore Orioles (AL) |
| 2002 | gelijk
Onvoldoende spelers | 7 - 7
(11 innings) | Miller Park, Milwaukee Brewers | geen |
| 2003 | American | 7 - 6 | U.S. Cellular Field, Chicago White Sox | Garret Anderson, Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim (AL) |
| 2004 | American | 9 - 4 | Minute Maid Park, Houston Astros | Alfonso Soriano, Texas Rangers (AL) |
| 2005 | American | 7 - 5 | Comerica Park, Detroit Tigers | Miguel Tejada, Baltimore Orioles (AL) |
| 2006 | American | 3 - 2 | PNC Park, Pittsburgh Pirates | Michael Young, Texas Rangers (AL) |
| 2007 | American | 5 - 4 | AT&T Park, San Francisco Giants | Ichiro Suzuki, Seattle Mariners (AL) |
| 2008 | American | 4 - 3
(15 innings) | Yankee Stadium, New York Yankees | J.D. Drew, Boston Red Sox (AL) |
| 2009 | American | 4 - 3 | Busch Stadium, St. Louis Cardinals | Carl Crawford, Tampa Bay Rays (AL) |
| 2010 | National | 3 - 1 | Angel Stadium of Anaheim, Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim | Brian McCann, Atlanta Braves (NL) |
| 2011 | National | 5 - 1 | Chase Field, Arizona Diamondbacks | Prince Fielder, Milwaukee Brewers (NL) |
| 2012 | National | 8 - 0 | Kauffman Stadium, Kansas City Royals | Melky Cabrera, San Francisco Giants (NL) |
| 2013 | American | 3 - 0 | Citi Field, New York Mets | Mariano Rivera, New York Yankees (AL) |
| 2014 | American | 5 - 3 | Target Field, Minnesota Twins | Mike Trout, Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim (AL) |
| 2015 | American | 6 - 3 | Great American Ball Park, Cincinnati Reds | Mike Trout, Los Angeles Angels of Anaheim (AL) |
| 2016 | American | 4 - 2 | Petco Park, San Diego Padres | Eric Hosmer, Kansas City Royals (AL) |
| 2017 | American | 2 - 1
(10 innings) | Marlins Park, Miami Marlins | Robinson Cano, Seattle Mariners (AL) |
| 2018 | American | 8 - 6 | Nationals Park, Washington Nationals | Alex Bregman, Houston Astros (AL) |
| 2019 | American | 4 - 3 | Progressive Field, Cleveland Indians | Shane Bieber, Cleveland Indians (AL) |
| 2020 | Niet gehouden vanwege de COVID-19 pandemie |
| 2021 | American | 5 - 2 | Coors Field, Colorado Rockies | Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Toronto Blue Jays (AL) |
| 2022 | American | 3 - 2 | Dodger Stadium, Los Angeles Dodgers | Giancarlo Stanton, New York Yankees (AL) |
| 2023 | National | 3 - 2 | T-Mobile Park, Seattle Mariners | Elías Díaz, Colorado Rockies (NL) |
| 2024 | - | - | Globe Life Field, Texas Rangers | - |
| 2025 | - | - | -, - | - |
| 2026 | - | - | Citizens Bank Park, Philadelphia Phillies | |
· 
· 